What if I told you that paying off all your debt might actually be slowing down your path to financial independence? Today, we’re diving into the controversial idea that not all debt is bad debt, and why keeping some debt might be the smartest move.
Hello, hello, hello and welcome to the Bigger Pockets Money Podcast. My name is Mindy Jensen and with me as always is my holds some debt co-host, Scott Trench.
Thanks, Mindy. Great to be here. Um, borrowing off of your intro, you’ve also got a mortgage these days, I believe, uh, and finally have some debt back in your life.
I sure do.
We recently had Erika on the podcast, uh, actually this Tuesday, and we heard her story about going from $90,000 in debt to a net worth of $2.5 million. It took her and her husband five years to pay off that debt. And during that time, they weren’t investing outside of a 401k match. So today, we’re going to talk about each of our personal stances on debt, and we’re going to frame the discussion around folks who have student loan debt or maybe some car debt and those types of things, and the nuances of personal situations where I might say, don’t pay off that debt and go invest aggressively. And when I might say, on the same debt, pay it off and make that your priority. It depends on the person and the context of their situation. I think this will be a fun one and I look forward to any feedback or thoughts here in the comments.
Yep, you can email Scott@biggerpocketsmoney.com or Mindy@biggerpocketsmoney.com or leave a comment below.
So let’s just introduce the concept here. Mindy, what do you think about having debt in a general sense, uh, during your fire journey? Do you currently have any debt? Did you have any as you were building your wealth? What did that look like?
So, Scott, I have never had debt outside of my mortgage on whatever house I was living in. I didn’t have any student loan debts. My parents paid for my college, which was the gift that it was so valuable for me to come out of college without student loan debts. How about you?
I’m very similar. My parents paid for college. Thank you very much, mom and dad, um, for that. That’s a wonderful gift. And all of my debt has been mortgages on real estate intended to be used as investments with the exception of a 1.99% car loan for my 2014 then new Toyota Corolla, um, that I paid off over five years.
Okay, so is debt, is it debt if there’s a 0% interest rate? Because I did borrow money to buy a car in 2010, but it was a 0% interest rate.
Yes, it’s debt if you if you have a 0% interest rate, right? Dave Ramsey won’t take a billion dollars at 0% famously, right? So I think it’s I think it’s a loan there.
If anybody wants to give me a billion dollars at 0%, you can email Mindy@biggerpocketsmoney.com.
Yeah, or me, yeah, absolutely. So this concept of good debt versus bad debt, right? You could argue that my car loan for my first car was bad debt, but it was such a low interest rate, um, that it was very hard for me to justify paying that off at that point in my life. And then, you know, of course, we we’ve talked about good debt backed by assets quite frequently here, but I will also say I was very highly leveraged in those in those early years on real estate. Multiple times my annual income, you know, 5% down kind of deal on properties. So that was a that was a big stretch to a certain degree there. Um, it was good debt in the sense that it was backed by an asset, but I did take some some serious risk, I guess, on those first few properties.
Yeah, so is good debt versus bad debt just one that’s backed by assets and one that isn’t or is it the I don’t know how I would pay this back if I lost my job, is that all bad debt?
I guess during the journey to fire, debt for me was a tool to compound my returns. It was a leverage, it was an intentional strategy of leveraging. And here, now, later in my journey, I see debt as a uh, more of a risk, right? Debt was offered much more reward on the journey to fire, and now it’s much more of a risk, relatively speaking, at this point in my journey. So I I use much, much less debt. There’s probably also a factor of rising interest rates and margin, changing market conditions that makes me feel that way about debt these days as well compared to how I felt about it 10 years ago.
I can understand that. It’s a lot easier to say, oh, I’ll take out a big mortgage because it’s only 3%. My mortgage payment is $1,500, whatever. And now your mortgage payment is 3,500 or 5,000 and that’s a lot less whatever.
What I think is really interesting and I think that a lot of people are grappling with is it’s very easy. You listen to Bigger Pockets money and you have 18% interest rate credit card debt that can’t be refinanced, you pay it off, right? Like like this is not, we’re not gonna like waste time on that part of the discussion. And I think also it’s gonna be very difficult for a lot of Bigger Pockets money listeners, at least on the early part of their journey to fire, to pay off the 1.99% car loan. I think it’s the in-between space that’s really interesting and unique, especially debt in that kind of six to 10% range, where when do I pay that off and get really aggressive about that and treat it like an emergency? And when do I ignore it and build assets and try to build wealth with better risk-adjusted investment opportunities outside that? And I think that’s the challenge that really eats at people or or gnaws at their brain and and and and makes them worry about whether they’re doing the optimal thing in their situation. And I thought that a good way to bring this discussion to life is to introduce two characters here. One one we’re gonna call Craig, and Craig is modeled off of my friend Craig Curlop who has been a guest here on bigger pockets money and a brief background on Craig in his early 20s joined Bigger Pockets as a financial analyst. So he worked for me and uh, I was in awe of this guy. He was, you know, I I thought I was frugal and hardcore on my journey to financial independence. My good God, Craig, Craig does it to a whole other level. He bought house hacks. He would live in the living room and short-term rental the bedroom while he lived behind a curtain rod that he, you know, that cut off a corner of his living room, right? He he of course drove a really a really cheap vehicle. He was constantly looking for side hustles. He got his agent license and started selling houses while working at bigger pockets. We he had a graduation day we called it from Bigger Pockets because he, you know, he was selling so much real estate that it was just a great opportunity for him to go and start his own brokerage. It didn’t make sense for him to to be the financial analyst at bigger pockets anymore. And so he he was a very entrepreneurial, very hardcore saver, very ambitious to get to financial freedom, very big thinker, self-taught, kind of I would say obsessive, I think he would agree with that to a certain extent over self-improvement and and building wealth for a big part of that that that journey. And and Craig also had, I think it was 80 some thousand, maybe more in student loan debt coming into that situation. And this was at high interest, right? Uh, 7 or 8%. So we’re going to talk about Craig’s example here. and we’re going to introduce his counterpart who we’re calling Carol, right? Carol has is uh kind of a more normal financial situation here, more normal approach to money. She is married, she’s got a husband, they’ve got $90,000 in debt, 60,000 of which is in student loans. and they’ve got a car loan, $30,000 at a 3.99%. They make 135k in household income, so they’re doing well. This is not this is not somebody who’s really struggling to get by, you know, earning earning 15, 20 bucks an hour and just early in their career. This is someone who’s a couple years in their career but is struggling with the decision about whether to pay down this debt or invest. They’re doing the responsible things. They’ve got a little bit of cash in the bank, maybe a month or two in emergency reserve. They spend about 100 grand a year and so they’re able to uh contribute partially but not all the way and fully max out the 401Ks. And they’re just wondering, what do we do next to get ahead on our journey? And I thought we could contrast these two situations. Let’s assume both student loan debts are at 7.5% interest. Mindy, should they both pay off the student loan debt or should they both invest? What do you think?
So, no, they should not both pay off their student loan debt right now because they have very different mentalities on what they’re doing, where they’re going, how they’re going to get there. The all-out approach of Craig is going to make his student loan debt unfortunate and kind of, you know, always be in the back of his mind. But he’s doing something different with the money that he would otherwise be throwing at his student loans. So, because he has a plan in place, I wouldn’t say he needs to pay off his student loans at this time. Yes, he needs to pay them off. He needs to keep making the minimum payments until he does. Carol doesn’t have the same plan. So, for her, she needs to pay off these student loan debts because she’s not thinking differently.
I think it’s completely right. I think it’s it’s a question of opportunity cost. Craig has incredible alternatives because of how little he spends, how entrepreneurial he is, and how willing he is to use high leverage and how willing he is to reduce risk by keeping his expenses so low and always trying new entrepreneurial things where they’re low risk and high upside. For Craig, a 7% yield is something that he he may get unlucky. He may even get unlucky for years with house hacks or the market working against him. But you know that the risk-adjusted probability of someone who lives in a house, rents out the other bedrooms of that house, runs it like a business and has plans to scale it while getting their agent license, that person should definitely not pay off their student loans in that situation. And I think that’s absolutely the correct choice and Craig made the correct choice. Now, the alternatives for Carol and her husband are different, right? They’re not willing or they’re not at least currently exhibiting the signs of entrepreneurship, the the all-out approach to building wealth that Craig is. And so their alternatives are not as attractive. And now we have a much harder choice, right? And that’s where I would bias them to paying off the student loan debt, unless something positive came around, like some some sort of major opportunity. Mindy, what would you bias for this couple as a order of operations for managing their money, knowing that their alternative is much more like investing for the long-term in stocks and tax advantage accounts rather than creative or entrepreneurial side hustles and pursuits.
All right, we’ve got to take a quick ad break, but while we’re away, head on over to YouTube and subscribe to our channel. That’s youtube.com/@biggerpocketsmoney.
Guest:
I’m skeptical of a lot of financial products, but life insurance isn’t one of them, at least not term life. For the vast majority of you listening, term life is simply the right answer. And the smartest way to buy it isn’t one big policy, it’s a ladder. Your need for coverage isn’t flat, it declines over time. You’ve got a 30-year mortgage, a couple of young kids, maybe a spouse in mid-career. In 15 years, the mortgage is going to be smaller, and the kids are almost launched. So, instead of buying one giant 30-year policy you’ll overpay for, you stack a few. Say a 10-year, a 20-year, and a 30-year layer. So your total coverage steps down as your actual obligations step down. You only pay for what you actually need when you need it. Ethos is a platform that helps you find life insurance 100% online. You can get a quote in seconds and apply in minutes. There’s no medical exam, you just answer a few health questions online. You can get up to 3 million in coverage. Some policies are as low as $30 a month. That makes building a ladder genuinely fast. Get your free quote at ethos.com/bpmoney. That’s ETHOS.com/bpmoney. Application times may vary and rates may vary. When spring hits, some people suddenly just want to declutter the garage, clean out the closets, and get everything all organized. Whether or not that hits you, Monarch will do your financial spring cleaning for you. One dashboard gets your entire financial life organized. No more clutter, no more mess, no more scattered logins, just accounts, investments, property, and more, all in one place. One of my favorite parts is the Sankey diagram. Every month, I open it up and literally watch the flow of money. It shows exactly where every dollar is going from income to all of my spending categories. It makes it so much easier to spot what’s working and what needs tweaking. Get your first year of Monarch for half off, just $50 with the promo code Pockets. Use the code Pockets at Monarch.com to get your first year half-off at just 50 bucks. That’s 50% off your first year at monarch.com with the code p o c k e t s. When you’re ready to start your business, Northwest registered agent helps you do more than just file paperwork. You get all the tools to build a real business identity from day one. A business address, website, phone number, operating agreement, free guides and more at no extra cost. Northwest Registered agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the US with over 1500 corporate guides. These are real people who know your local laws and can help you and your business every step of the way. With Northwest, your business is set up to stand on its own from day one. That means your home address, personal email and phone number stay private. Don’t pay hundreds or thousands of dollars for what you can get from Northwest for free. Visit northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree and start using free resources to build something amazing. Get more with Northwest registered agent at northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree.
Scott:
All right, welcome back to the show.
Mindy:
So, assuming that they have a match from their company, I would encourage them to first contribute to get the full match and then I would also, Scott, I am a huge fan of the Roth plans, the Roth IRA, the Roth 401k if that is something that you can contribute to if your company offers that. But because they’re making, what are they making? 100, they make 135,000 a year. So they are able to contribute to a Roth. A Roth contribution right now is 7,000 or 7,500 a year. So both of them could contribute to that, they would take the rest and throw it at their student loan debt. I would also encourage them to first have a emergency fund so that they’re not constantly throwing more money on their credit cards, but I really want them to set up their future selves while taking care of these student loan debts and these car debts. How about you?
Scott:
That’s interesting you say the the Roth, I would have initially biased towards the 401K, right? Someone has a very long time horizon to invest in this situation, but I think at that income level it’s going to be very close and they should do the math and and think it through on whether it’ll be better to invest in the Roth or the 401K. for them. But I agree, I agree. I think you I think you take the match and then you max out one or both of those retirement accounts and you let time pass. And anything left over you then apply toward the student loan debts at that point.
Mindy:
Well, because she’s so young, because Carol and her husband are so young, I want to see them maxing out their Roth now so that it has all this time to grow tax-free. When she pulls it out at the end of her journey at 59 and a half or whatever, she’s pulling out all that money tax-free as opposed to putting it in the 401k. I don’t want to say she’s only making 135,000, but she’s making 135,000, reducing her taxable income is probably not going to be foremost in her mind. I’m looking at the giant amount of growth that she is going to pay zero taxes on.
Scott:
I think we’ll have some tax pros quibble with us, but I think I’m with you on the Roth. I think that’s right. I think you I think you take the 401k match, you max out the Roth in the situation, and then you pay off the student loan debt. Now, what begins to change that for you? What if that student loan debt was at 6%?
Mindy:
6%, I would, I might put a little bit more in the 401k depending on where they’re coming in and the tax brackets because I do like the reduction of the taxable income that a traditional 401k offers. I might actually, I might encourage her to, because they don’t have enough extra money to max out the 401k and the Roth IRA and the HSAs. I would encourage them to first contribute to the 401k to get the match, then max out the Roth and the HSA because the HSA is also gross tax-free.
Scott:
Now, what if the student loan debt was 8.5% instead of 7.5%?
Mindy:
I really don’t like 8% debt. I would probably pull back on the HSA a little bit so that I could pay off those student loans faster. I would also encourage her husband who is in sales to be taking all of his commissions, all of his extra bonus money and throwing that at the debt as well.
Scott:
Yeah, I think at 8.5%, my mentality begins to shift more towards just taking the 401k match and paying off the debt. Or if I can, if I if I can refinance it, that’s great. But the reason for that, I think is that at 8.5%, the interest rate is high enough and the student loans are enough of a drag on my ability to produce free cash flow in my life that that becomes a higher priority. The Roth is a great benefit 30, 40 years from now for Carol, but paying off that student loan at 8.5% will be a big weight off now and a lot can happen between now and, you know, from from now and 30 years. And it’s also going to be fairly close, I think, on a nominal sense, to what is the historical rate of return in the stock market. Because it’s a guaranteed return and it’s so close to what the stock market has historically averaged, I’d be tempted to pay that off. And I would also be a little bit if I said that, you know, present day all-time high valuations wouldn’t also be at the back of my mind at that point in time here in late 2025, right? Obviously the market could balloon and that could go, you know, that could look silly in in hindsight, but I I would be very uncomfortable keeping all that debt instead investing in all-time high stock market valuations uh at that level. And I think that that would begin to change for me at 7.5% or 6% in Carol’s situation, which is why this situation is so interesting from a financial analysis standpoint, such a hard and painful decision because there’s no right answer to it. But this is how I would think about it an that situation.
Mindy:
Yeah, and you’re asking me what I would tell Carol. Real-life Mindy would be throwing every dollar I could at that debt because I don’t want 8.5% debt. I don’t want 7.5% debt. I am very debt averse, so I would want to be paying that off as soon as I could.
Scott:
Now, let’s change things again. Let’s say that Carol is no, I just discovered fire and that is my number one financial priority and I’m willing now to house hack. I’m willing to, you know, live in a in a uh, a very cheap, much cheaper location. I’m willing to sell my car and buy an economy vehicle. I’m willing to pack lunch most days. I’m going to vacation, but I’m going to do it, you know, on travel rewards or whatever, some some sort of way to to get that really cheaper or drive somewhere. Um with it. Now, how does that change things for you with the 7.5% interest, the the uh $60,000 in 7.5% interest student loan debt? Do we now still have her go through the the tax-advantaged accounts?
Mindy:
I would continue to have her get the match. I would continue to encourage her to max out her Roth IRA and to max out her HSA because you can cash flow your medical expenses right now and then pull that money out later. Again, it’s 7.5%. If she wants to hit fire, that’s like you said, that’s a guaranteed 7.5% return. We keep getting these notices that we’re going to go in a recession. What is it? Every year since 2013, we’ve been getting predictions that there’s going to be a recession coming up. So having that guaranteed 7.5% return is something that’s hard to overlook. I don’t think I would change my recommendations. Scott, how about you?
Scott:
Everything would change at that point for me, right? It’s because the alternatives now are substantially better. The alternatives for the use of cash for Carol in her early 20s or mid 20s, wherever wherever we are on this journey, is so much higher from a return perspective now that we’re willing to make that mindset shift and and go more all out. We reduce our risk of ever defaulting on the student loans because we’re going to drastically cut our spending, right? You make 135k a year and you go from $100,000 in spending to $60,000 in spending. That’s an enormous difference in cash accumulation after tax. And so I would take the 401k match in that situation and I’d stock pile 25, 30, $40,000 in cash and I would use that cash uh over the next 6 to 12 months to house hack, live in flip or have one of the spouses either start a business or take a job with much more upside than what is currently offered by the two base salary jobs averaging about $65,000 a year. That would be the returns there would be so much higher on a risk adjusted basis over a long period of time that it would dwarf the seven and a half percent guaranteed return of paying off the debt. And this is only a small window in life, right? In your when your when you’re early and getting started and have very little very little asset base, right? If they had, you know, a million dollar portfolio, then we’re talking we have a completely different situation that we’re going to talk through, right? Then I would pay off the debt um at that point because that would be a wonderful allocation to get a 7.5% guaranteed yield on a portion of a million-dollar portfolio. But at this point in their life, I think that if they’re willing to do all those changes, all of a sudden the risk profile is drastically reduced because our spending went way down and the opportunity cost of paying off that debt has skyrocketed because of our willingness to do something entrepreneurial or to uh house sack or do something with real estate.
Mindy:
Okay, that’s fair.
Scott:
Awesome. So, so in that case, my order of operations would be, take your 401k match, don’t contribute to the Roth, don’t contribute to the 401k at all. A mass cash and deploy it, whether that is deployed in a house hack or on a job opportunity or an entrepreneurial venture doesn’t matter. And then after one year, this is not like don’t invest in your 401k or your Roth for a long time, but after one or maybe two years, you go back to maxing those out with an order of operations once you’ve had a couple of repetitions with these bets and um, have put them into play. and now with our extra cash flow, we can begin maxing out the tax-advantaged accounts again.
Mindy:
If you are listening to this show and you think, oh, that sounds great. I’ll just stop contributing to my 401k, rewind a couple of minutes and listen to Scott again. This is a very specific scenario that he is describing not contributing to a 401k for a year.
Scott:
This is again, an all-out approach and and again, that’s I think the nuance of when and where to pay off this middling debt, right? This this 6 to 9% interest rate debt. We get this question all the time and it’s both a factor of your investment alternatives and then how hardcore you are going to be willing to be in your in your life in a general sense. Because if you’re willing to be more like Craig Curlop and go all out, then again, that that’s a time when it makes sense to defer paying even high interest rate debt. One trap I’ll call out there. Occasionally, I’ll meet folks I think are Craig Curlop, right? Who say they’re Craig Curlop, who say they’re going to go all out. And years go by, two, three years go by and no cash ever piles up in the bank account. And if no cash is piling up in the bank account and you are thinking that you’re living really frugally and working really hard, something’s wrong. And this does not apply there, right? This is a rare persona, but then that is something is wrong and I would encourage you to go debt free if you’ve been at this for three, four years and you think you’re living frugally and and trying to amass this cash, I would pay that down. And I think that that’s a real red flag as well if you’re thinking about, you know, a house hack or something like that and you just can’t accumulate the 15, 20, 30,000 over a a year or three period for the down payment. I think you’re going to have a really hard time doing these kind of entrepreneurial or real estate investing activities if for whatever reason it just doesn’t seem like cash can come into your life. That has to be resolved for a year or two before you you can really put yourself in that bucket of the all-out person pursuing these other opportunities.
Mindy:
Yeah, and I think that the problem of I just can’t seem to amass cash is a disconnect between what you think you’re spending and what you’re actually spending. And there’s a really easy fix for that. Track your spending. Track every dollar that comes out of your pocket in whatever way you want. Track it on a piece of paper where you have to write it down all the time. That’s kind of a pain in the side, but it makes you focus on how much you’re spending. Monarch Money is a great spending tracker, net worth tracker that can show you exactly where. It’s it’s better if you are not paying with a lot of cash, you’re instead doing a lot of swiping, it instantly pops up on your dashboard. You spent this much today. Oh, well, I really thought I only spent this much. I forgot about that one purchase or those five purchases. It’s so easy to forget about things that you’re spending and I see a lot of people who think they’re spending here but they’re actually spending here or here and that is going to be the difference between being able to amass cash and being able to do these entrepreneurial things.
Scott:
All right, this is our final ad break. It will be right back with more after this.
Guest:
If you’ve been putting off life insurance, I get it. The old process was miserable. Phone calls with an agent, a nurse coming to your house for a blood draw, then waiting weeks to find out what you pay for. That friction is exactly why so many people who should have coverage don’t. Here’s what I believe. Most BP money listeners need term life and the right move is to build a ladder. A few term policies of different lengths stacked together so your coverage steps down as your mortgage shrinks and your kids get closer to being financially independent or you get closer to hitting your financial independence number. The thing that makes that practical now is Ethos, a platform that helps you find life insurance all 100% online. Same day coverage, no medical exam, you just answer a few health questions online. Up to $3 million in coverage. Some policies as low as $30 a month. So building a two or three-layer ladder that used to take a month of appointments is something you can knock out before your coffee gets cold. Get your free quote at ethos.com/bpmoney. That is e t h o s.com/bpmoney. Application times may vary and rates may vary. When the change in season hits, some people suddenly just want to declutter the garage, clean up the closets, and get everything all organized. And that’s great. If that’s you, or if it’s not you, either way, let Monarch do the financial spring cleaning this year for you. One dashboard gets your entire financial life organized. No more clutter, no more mess, no more scattered logins, just accounts, investments, property, and more, all in one place. Another feature I love about Monarch is the weekly AI recap. It catches spending spikes before they become problems and flags big net worth shifts or upcoming expenses. It’s like having a quick personal check-in every week so nothing sneaks up on me. Get your first year of Monarch for half off, just 50 bucks with the promo code Pockets. Use the code Pockets at monarch.com to get your first year half off at just $50. That’s 50% off your first year at monarch.com with the code Pockets P O C K E T S. When you’re ready to start your business, Northwest Registered agent helps you do more than just file paperwork. You get all the tools to build a real business identity from day one. A business address, website, phone number, operating agreement, free guides and more at no extra cost. Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the US with over 1500 corporate guides. These are real people who know your local laws and can help you in your business every step of the way. With Northwest, your business is set up to stand on its own from day one. That means your home address, personal email and phone number stay private. Don’t pay hundreds or thousands of dollars for what you can get from Northwest for free. Visit northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree and start using free resources to build something amazing. Get more with Northwest registered agent at northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree.
Scott:
All right, welcome back from the ads.
Mindy:
Thanks for sticking with us.
Scott:
Let’s continue these scenarios because I think this is this is fun here. I have another example of a persona I’m going to call him Harold. Harold is a real person, not their real name. And Harold I meet occasionally uh here in the Denver area and just kind of catch up with. It’s interesting because Harold started his career two years ago now, I guess, and was making around the same amount that I made when I started my career, adjusted for inflation. So I started as a financial analyst at a Fortune 500 company. And Harold is a rocket scientist at a at Lockheed Martin, right? And he’s thinking, ah, should I house hack and go on entrepreneurship and all these kinds of things. And the answer is, heck no. Even though Harold is accumulating cash, living frugally and all those types of things, Harold is a rocket scientist from a top university. In seven to 10 years, Harold is going to be making several hundred thousand per year at least, with lots of opportunity. There’s every reason to believe in that career trajectory. My career trajectory would have been okay as a financial analyst, right? I would have I would have climbed the ranks and maybe made just over $150,000 around this time in my career um at age 35. Harold will not have that problem. If he performs, he will make a tremendous amount of money in one of the most lucrative career fields known to man. And I get this question a lot from people in the Carol and Craig situation as well. Craig was doing great. He came out of college and joined bigger pockets there. He was an entrepreneur of an entrepreneur, but he didn’t have like a guaranteed trajectory at Facebook or Meta, you know, or same thing or or Nvidia or Google, right? If you’re in that situation, then I think again the rules don’t apply. Like there’s no alternative outside of what you’re doing that can possibly match the opportunity at your career and just climbing the ranks at one of these elite jobs out of college, right? It’s so much income, such a clear path to the top 1% in America uh over a 5, 10-year period if you perform, that that’s the obvious play, right? Then then why are you wasting your time on a duplex that’s really dumpy uh over in this part of the city. Why are you wasting your time trying to sell winter rental gloves, uh which is an idea I had that was terrible when I was, you know, 23 or whatever at that point in time. You’re wasting your time. That’s it’s the situation is different and now you’re back to paying off your debt. Just just be like, look, the asset here is my career. I’m going to invest according to a clear tax-advantaged order of operations. I’m going to invest passively, and I’m going to make my career go really well. And this confuses, I think, some of the folks that are early on in the journey who don’t see that there’s an obvious separation in their career potential. If you join Lockheed Martin as a rocket scientist, compared to two teachers who are going to be making a more clear um career trajectory path. And again, the math changes in these situations around. So what do you think Mindy?
Mindy:
I think that if Harold truly wants to house hack, then he can. But that, like you said, that shouldn’t be his focus. Definitely not a live-in flip, especially if he’s DIYing the process, because that’s just that takes away your focus from your main income source. People who house hack, that can be their main income source. That can be a huge chunk towards their income. But if he’s going to have a multiple six-figure salary very near future, then wasting your mental space on these extraneous endeavors isn’t the right choice.
Scott:
I think that’s the challenge is there’s some situations that seem very obvious to me as a 35-year-old who’s met with a lot of uh of these kind of like very ambitious 20-somethings because I’ve spent their life and here and you’re like, okay, well, obviously you should be house hacking and doing these things. These are great moves. You’re going to you’re going to do really well. That will diversify your income streams away from your career and allow you to be an entrepreneur and and go on to be very successful at some point. And then there’s the situation of like, well, you have one of the best jobs you’re ever going to see coming out of college here and like the opportunities available in entrepreneurship will just never map to that the same way unless you go and build one of these huge, you know, alternative investment banking firms or whatever, which still probably depends on you building up enough experience to be respected and connections in the field that you’ve chosen over a 5 to 10 year period. and it’s just so much higher odds and potentially higher quality of life for some of those folks to achieve financial freedom that way. Again, that’s what I’m I’m talking about here. And for those people, I think the answer is pay off your debt. Don’t invest in all these alternatives because it’s going to be completely irrelevant to the outcome 10 years from now. Um which will be mostly predicated on your income generation.
Mindy:
So, Scott, once you have decided to pay off your debt, what are you doing?
Scott:
If I’m committed to paying off debt, I think the two schools of thought are going to be the avalanche and the snowball, right? The avalanche being where we pay off the highest interest rate debt first and the snowball where we’re paying we’re paying off the lowest balance debt first. And I think that there’s kind of two scenarios here. One is let’s let’s take Carol’s situation. Carol does not have a debt problem, right? The debt is a problem, but but it’s not like Carol is an is a track record of of racking up debt, not paying attention to her situation or making large amounts of financial mistakes in a general sense. Carol has student loan debt and she needed a car. And she got low interest rate to loan debt. She probably has good good credit score, whatever. In this scenario, I’m a big proponent of the avalanche method where we have a seven and a half percent interest rate on the student loans and we have a 3.99% rate on the car loan, I’m paying off the student loans even though the the balance is larger. That’s just good financial math. If we were talking about a situation where someone had a couple hundred thousand in debt with Carol’s income, and that was spread across credit cards and parking tickets and medical debt and student loans and car loans. Now we have what I would call more of a debt problem, either through bad luck or financial mismanagement, we’ve accumulated a large number of debts and held them for a long period of time. And that is not a mathematical problem anymore, it’s a psychological problem. This is when you go to Dave Ramsey and you use the snowball method and you attack that debt as a first priority and you’re not really doing investment analysis math behind the decision. What do you think?
Mindy:
I understand both schools of thought. The debt avalanche is you’re paying off the highest interest rate first. The debt snowball is you’re paying off the lowest amount first and getting that psychological win to continue going because it’s difficult to tackle the biggest amount of debt and you never really see it changing. You could get this mentality of, uh, why bother? I guess I’ll just always be in debt forever. I have my own that I have called cleverly the Mindy method, uh, where you make two lists. Your first list is your debts in order of the smallest amount owed to the largest amount owed, so the debt snowball. And then the second one is your debts in the order of the highest interest rate to the lowest interest rate. And then you start with one or the other, it doesn’t matter. You tackle the top debt while paying the minimums on all the rest. And then you flip over to the other side. So if you start on debt avalanche, then you flip over to the debt snowball and pay that top one off as aggressively as possible. And then you go back. So you’re getting the the mathematical win of paying off your highest interest rate while getting the psychological win to keep going of paying off your lowest debt amount. You see these wins, you’ve knocked off, now you’ve knocked off two, and then you can go back to the other one. Eventually you’ll get to zero debt, but if you struggle with staying on course and, you know, I don’t really see any debt that I’m making in this debt, then the Mindy method is a nice hybrid.
Scott:
To put that into Carol’s context, right? Let’s say that Carol’s student loans at 7.5%, $60,000 balance and she had a car loan of $30,000 at 7%, just just 500 basis points lower, then I’d be tempted to pay off the car loan first because it’s so close in interest rate that we we’re we’re beginning to blend a little bit of psychology and math in that situation and I’d be tempted to pay it off, the smaller balance debt off that’s only slightly lower interest rate.
Mindy:
Either way, whatever you’re doing to pay off your debt is the best choice for you. Just, again, make sure it’s intentional. It’s not just haphazard. And there are some people who absolutely cannot handle having any debt at all. And there are some people who are completely fine with it, knowing that they’re using it as a tool of some sort. So, Craig Curlop, you can hear his episode where he talks about all of this in his real-life story is episode 35. But Craig Curlop, he used his debt instead of paying it off, he used that money in a different way, much like we suggested to the fictitious Craig here. But there are people who just cannot fathom the idea of having debt. And if that is where you are, then absolutely give yourself some mental space and start paying down your debt. The math doesn’t matter if you can’t sleep.
Scott:
I completely agree with that. If if if there’s a psychological factor behind this, that could potentially trump all of the math and the analysis, you know, around what these interest rates talk about and you just pay off your debt if that’s you. I think that a fire, like a healthy attitude towards debt in the context of the financial independence retire early the fire journey is to use debt as a tool in the early days of the fire journey. And and I’m a big proponent of going hardcore for the first three to five years. I think that there’s a tendency in the fire community to go too hard, too long and death march it to fi once even after millions of dollars have been accumulated. But I think that there’s also a forgetfulness of how important it is to get that snowball rolling early in life and how hard it is to get that rolling and the rewards that compound forever after that. So I think that it is important and I think during that period, using debt as a tool is is great. One factor to watch out for is, look, if I’m if I’m house hacking at 23 and I’m making $60,000 a year and getting 250,000 in debt or, you know, making $85,000 a year and getting $300 some thousand in debt. That’s an all-in bet and it’s it’s a calculated risk, but it’s not really more risky than your peer who’s buying a house that does not have tenants that could potentially help out with the mortgage. Once you rack up $3 million in debt and you’re making 200 grand in your salary, now all of a sudden, your dependent on your portfolio and your portfolio can work against you real fast in the market. The great thing about real estate is there’s nothing to do about the prices. Once you put your property to highest and best use, you keep it occupied, nothing you do. It’s just goes up or goes down with the market. And long term, that’s a great feature of real estate. And every couple years, every every once in a while, the market’s going to go down, and if you’re highly levered and forced to sell in those periods of pullback, which you always are, right? Down environments is when rent stops coming in, when the tenants have relative power in the relationship and begin to treat the property worse, causing more repairs, and when property prices pull back, and when interest rates go up, right? It all hits at once uh in those environments or it tends to over the over the years and it gets harder to borrow. and that’s what you have to fear as a real estate investor and be very respectful of. It’s easy to forget that, I think, if you’re investing in periods like 2019 through 2021 and it’s very easy to remember that here in 2025.
Mindy:
Yes. It’s uh, what is it? Hindsight is 2020.
Scott:
Yeah, so again, the healthy healthy relationship with debt on the fire journey is again, to to to put a bow on it, is going to be, yes, I may be willing to use debt, especially if I’m spending much less than I earn and that can propel me forward on my fire journey. And I’m not going to just continuously maintain high leverage in perpetuity because you know that that is a high probability of going BK at some point in time. At some point you begin the deleveraging process as you transition and and you get closer to your goals. That’s a more healthy relationship and many people can’t stop um going after it and I think that they’re going to get a wake up call at some point.
Mindy:
I agree, Scott. Absolutely agree. The debt can be a tool but you have to use it strategically. You put thought into it. Just like anything else. Don’t just blindly follow what some Yahoo on the internet says. Do your research, put your thought into it. Why are you using this debt? How are you going to use this debt? What is your plan, you know, down the road? What is your plan for the payoff, etc. etc.
Scott:
Absolutely.
Mindy:
All right, Scott. I think this was a super fun discussion. Should we get out of here?
Scott:
Let’s do it.
Mindy:
That wraps up this episode of the Bigger Pockets Money Podcast. He is Scott Trench. I am Mindy Jensen saying, got to go UFO. and we
Guest:
When you’re ready to start your business, Northwest registered agent helps you do more than just file paperwork. You get all the tools to build a real business identity from day one. A business address, website, phone number, operating agreement, free guides and more at no extra cost. Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the US with over 1500 corporate guides. These are real people who know your local laws and can help you and your business every step of the way. With Northwest, your business is set up to stand on its own from day one. That means your home address, personal email and phone number stay private. Don’t pay hundreds or thousands of dollars for what you can get from Northwest for free. Visit northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree and start using free resources to build something amazing. Get more with Northwest registered agent at northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree.
Mindy:
would love to hear your comments below. Oh, that rhyme too.
