What if you could access your retirement funds years before traditional retirement age without paying hefty penalties? Today’s Finance Friday guest is hoping to retire by the age of 45, but she doesn’t have a really clear understanding of the investing order of operations and what is best, quote unquote. Today, we are going to break down the options that she has to make her FIRE dream a reality in just 14 years. This is a great episode if you’re worried about the middle class trap and how to make sure it doesn’t get in your way of financial freedom.
Hello, hello, hello and welcome to the BiggerPockets Money podcast. My name is Mindy Jensen and with me while Scott Trench is out on paternity leave is Amberly Grant.
Hello, I’m happy to be back here, hanging out with you, Mindy.
I’m so excited you’re here.
All right, guys. I’m going to put on my best Scott impression. Hopefully better than last time. BiggerPockets has a goal of creating one million millionaires. You’re in the right place if you want to get your financial house in order because we truly believe that financial freedom is attainable for everyone, no matter what or when or where you have started.
I think you’re really starting to get that. Again, Scott’s voice is a little lower, but that was spot on.
Okay, Kat, thank you so much for joining us today. We are so excited to talk to you.
Yay. Thank you so much for having me, Mindy. Thank you, Amberly. So nice to meet you guys.
It’s nice to meet you. Kat, can you share where your journey with money begins?
I can. Um, so I was brought up in the middle class and my parents really like set the stage for me in terms of money and how to work with money. And ultimately, they taught me a few values. They taught me a value of frugality and they taught me a value of generosity. And the value of frugality, um, even though, you know, we could afford all the things we needed to afford, like you can see that my mom still has her 1998 Honda Civic and I think it’s indestructible at this point. I always have been a saver. I’ve had a piggy bank under my bed since I was a kid. And that was great, except I never really like put my money into a high-yield savings account. Like I didn’t know about that. Like my parents, I’ve always like trusted them explicitly or implicitly with everything and like my parents always invested for me, which was great. We were investing except I didn’t realize we were investing in only a few stocks. It was fine when we were invested in Apple in the early, you know, 2000s. But then over time, there was just a few stocks that we’re in and those didn’t do well. And I’m at the early stages of my life. So for me, I can pivot, um, and I was lucky enough to graduate without debt in school, and I was able to buy a house. So I have like a good setup for myself. But, you know, it’s of course different for my parents because they’re a bit later in life.
And so I just started realizing like I can’t just trust other people with taking care of me. Like I also have to make sure I’m taking care of myself with my finances. Woman with a master’s degree in chemistry, like I should know more about my money. And then my friend Anna Banana, um, we were in Ireland together and she told me about this FIRE movement. I was like, what the heck is that? I’m like, I can’t retire early. I’m a teacher. But I just been absorbing your podcast, like literally it’s delicious to me. And um, so yeah, I am I’m grateful to be here and, um, to share my story. So thanks.
Thank you so much, Kat for sharing all of that. Um, it’s really nice to hear, you know, where you come from because it really does inform where you’re going. You mentioned you’re a teacher. Can you tell us a little bit about how far into teaching you are, what maybe state you teach in. Yeah, tell us that.
I am a science research teacher in New York State and it is my seventh year teaching. Um, but I am on step eight. We have like a step system for salary, um, from some of my other experiences with AmeriCorps they counted that towards my steps.
Excellent. That’s really nice. And do you do something outside of teaching as well?
Not anything that really like brings home the bank, but I, I get some money for the specialty class I teach, science research, because it takes a lot of time outside of the school day. And I also tutor like every week, every weekend.
Excellent. And you mentioned you’re in a step system. So what is your current salary?
My current salary is around 87 to $88,000 and if I add my stipend as a research teacher then it’s closer to like $90,000.
Excellent. Congrats on that. At 30 years old, that is awesome. Like really, really great.
I wasn’t making $90,000 at age 30.
I think New York State is one of the highest paid uh teacher salaries. So I do think I have uh advantage in that regard, but we also are one of the most expensive places to live. So.
I was just going to ask, would you characterize your area as high cost of living or medium cost of living?
I would characterize it as medium to high. It’s hard for me to compare it when I’ve only really lived in New York, but um, I remember traveling to a few other places and I was like, this is still pretty expensive in like places around the country where I thought things would be cheaper. So I would say definitely, it’s not New York City prices where I live, but it’s very close to that. Yeah.
Kat, what is your retirement goal?
My retirement goal is kind of a rough goal of being able to retire by around 45. Um, I know that I will need if I was to completely retire, about 1.2 million. That is based on the 4% rule that you guys talk about a lot. It’s all kind of estimates, but.
So 1.2 million, that is a great number. Let’s look at your actual numbers right now. I’ve got a net worth of $388,000. That’s pretty awesome for a teacher. That’s pretty awesome for somebody in their early 30s. Uh that’s pretty awesome all the way around for just an American at any age, at any salary because Americans are, you know, more paycheck to paycheck. So that’s broken up into uh $40,000 in a 403B, $16,000 in a Roth IRA, $11,000 in a brokerage account, $2,000 in a 529 plan. I do see $42,000 in cash. I’ll ask you about that in a little bit. And I see about $300,000 in uh home equity, 250, $300,000 depending on that. So currently I don’t think that you have enough to retire, but you’re not trying to retire at 32, you’re trying to retire at 45. So we do have a timeline horizon that I think is pretty doable, especially because you’re making $90,000.
Uh, let’s look at, let’s look at all the income. Do you and your partner combine finances?
At this time, we do not. He contributes to um, my mortgage because the the house is in my name currently. And we kind of do like every other for groceries. So he pays me essentially as part of like, you know, taking off some money from the mortgage.
So I see a grand total of household income of 134,000. But since you don’t share expenses, let’s say 90,000 for you plus $2,000 in a 1099, is that the tutoring that you were talking about?
Oh, yeah, that is the side tutoring. Mhm.
Okay. And then I see $900 in other income. So that is what, 92, 93,000. That’s great. Uh, current expenses I have is 3601. So we’ve got the mortgage payment of 800, groceries of 400, restaurants at 300, um, entertainment at nine dollars. Slow down, Kat. I don’t know what you’re doing with that nine whole dollars, but come on. You’re trying to reach financial independence. A hundred and fifty for travel, 300 for utilities, $20 for clothing, 400 for shopping, 122 for insurance. I don’t see anything really crazy in these expenses. And I’m going to do some quick math here, times 12 is 43,000. You’re bringing in $93,000 and you’re spending 43,000. I think you’re doing all right. Woo!
I see debts of $14,000 at 0% interest. I wouldn’t pay that off any sooner than you had to, or any sooner than that uh 0% interest would go away. I do see a pension with a potential value of $99,000 a year. That’s nothing to sneeze at, except you’re only seven years into what, a 20 year commitment?
It would be actually 30 uh two more years of teaching in order for me to get that at the current pension system that I have. So that is part of my motivation for looking into if I can FIRE. Um, I do think that there’s a likely chance that will change because our union in New York State is pretty strong and so they’ll try to get that to 55, which is where tier four teachers are currently at. Um, but I don’t know. So I want to make sure I’m taking care of myself so that, you know, if I don’t want to work until I’m 62 and they don’t change it, then I don’t have to.
Now we need to take a quick ad break. But listeners, I am so excited to announce you can now buy your ticket for BPCON 2025, which is October 5th through 7th in Las Vegas, Nevada. Score the early bird pricing for $100 off your ticket by going to biggerpockets.com/conference. While we’re away.
When you’re ready to start your business, Northwest Registered Agent helps you do more than just file paperwork. You get all the tools to build a real business identity from day one. A business address, website, phone number, operating agreement, free guides and more at no extra cost. Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the US with over 1500 corporate guides. These are real people who know your local laws and can help you in your business every step of the way. With Northwest, your business is set up to stand on its own from day one. That means your home address, personal email and phone number stay private. Don’t pay hundreds or thousands of dollars for what you can get from Northwest for free. Visit northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree and start using free resources to build something amazing. Get more with Northwest Registered Agent at northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree.
When spring hits, some people suddenly just want to declutter the garage, clean out the closets, and get everything all organized. Whether or not that hits you, Monarch will do your financial spring cleaning for you. One dashboard gets your entire financial life organized. No more clutter, no more mess, no more scattered logins, just accounts, investments, property, and more, all in one place. One of my favorite parts is the Sankey diagram. Every month, I open it up and literally watch the flow of money. It shows exactly where every dollar is going from income to all of my spending categories. It makes it so much easier to spot what’s working and what needs tweaking. Get your first year of Monarch for half off, just $50 with the promo code POCKETS. Use the code POCKETS at Monarch.com to get your first year half off at just 50 bucks. That’s 50% off your first year at monarch.com with the code P O C K E T S.
I’m skeptical of a lot of financial products, but life insurance isn’t one of them. At least not term life. For the vast majority of you listening, term life is simply the right answer. And the smartest way to buy it isn’t one big policy, it’s a ladder. Your need for coverage isn’t flat, it declines over time. You’ve got a 30-year mortgage, a couple of young kids, maybe a spouse mid-career. In 15 years, the mortgage is going to be smaller and the kids are almost launched. So instead of buying one giant 30-year policy you’ll overpay for, you stack a few, say a 10 year, a 20 year and a 30 year layer, so your total coverage steps down as your actual obligations step down. You only pay for what you actually need when you need it. Ethos is a platform that helps you find life insurance 100% online. You can get a quote in seconds and apply in minutes. There’s no medical exam. You just answer a few health questions online. You can get up to 3 million in coverage. Some policies are as low as $30 a month. That makes building a ladder genuinely fast. Get your free quote at ethos.com/bpmoney. That’s E T H O S.com/bpmoney. Application times may vary and rates may vary.
Welcome back to the show. We are joined by Kat. I’m going to read a quote that comes from your application. I realized what I really want is time freedom more than anything else. So one of your questions for us was, is it silly to retire at 45 when I could be a lot wealthier if I waited another 10 years? No, it’s not silly to retire at 45 even though you could be wealthier. You know what? You’d be even more wealthier if you waited another 20 years and you’d be even more wealthier if you waited another 30 years. You could just work forever. You want time freedom. You are seven years into a 39-year commitment. I don’t think I would be looking at that pension as something that I was going to be able to collect. I would be putting it to the side. Should the rules change and you are able to collect even a dollar from it, yay. And that is where my pension knowledge ends. So I am going to send you on a little homework assignment. Oh, you’re a teacher. Here’s homework for you. Episode 259 of the BiggerPockets Money podcast, we spoke with somebody who go, he’s anonymous. He goes by the name Grumpus Maximus. And he talked to us all about pensions, how to value your pension, how to see if it’s even worth pursuing, um, and it’s been a minute since he shared all of that. I’ve recorded, I don’t know, 400 episodes since then. So I don’t remember all of the things that he shared with us. But luckily we recorded it. So you can go and listen to that episode. Um, start doing a little bit of homework on your pension. Talk to your HR department or whatever the equivalent is and ask them what happens if I don’t retire at 55? What happens if I retire at 45? Is there like an age minimum where if I don’t work until that age, I don’t get anything at all. And then I would, I would just not even worry about this or consider this pension right now. And everybody listening who has pensions, we’re like, no, it’s worth money. Great. I’m sending her on a homework assignment so she can determine how much this is worth. Um, but I think first of all, at age 31, you’re in a great financial position. Your goal is to retire in 14 years. I think that’s doable. Um, you asked what age should you stop contributing to your 403B and instead put it into a brokerage account. Amberly, do you have any information, any uh, ideas about that?
Well, first of all, I wanted to ask and step back here and say in retirement, do you expect your expenses to stay the same? Because when I’m looking here at your number of $1.2 million, that is about $4,000 a month in, uh, you know, take home essentially, um, pay for yourself to cover those expenses that are now at $3,600. So there’s only about a $400 buffer. Um, what are you thinking about for your expenses when you’re approximately 45 years old?
I think that my goal is to pay off my mortgage by then. So that should lower my monthly payment by about a thousand dollars. So I it would it would free up a thousand dollars. I would like to retire after I pay off my mortgage so that that’s taken care of. Yeah.
I have to ask, um, I know dogs are life. Are you planning on adding any other creatures or um, spawn to your life in the next 15 years?
Yes, thank you for asking. That is a big part of the equation is whether or not um I add spawn to to my life and I don’t know. I am decided I did start a 529 as Mindy read out before and part of that was, maybe I would one day and I want to make sure it’s the spawn would be ready. I don’t know why I am still calling them a spawn. But um, you know, I’m I’m not um, convinced of that because I have a great life and I love my current dogs. And so, yeah, right now I’m planning as if I’m not having kids and I’ll just donate that 529 to a kid in need. Um, but it’s a possibility. I don’t know what the future holds for me.
Perfect. Yes, because I wanted to know that just because kids always change the equation if we do end up uh going that direction. But with life, um, you can pivot every single time something new jumps in. That’s when you take, uh, you know, a look at the environment that you’re in and say, hey, is this still my goal or does my goal change based on the new inputs? So I think that’s okay. Um, and it’s okay not to know right now and we’ll just continue moving forward as if it’s a no. And then you can make a choice later on. All right. When you’re saying you’re going to pay down your mortgage, um, uh, so that you’re mortgage-free in about 15 years, um, I’m looking at you’re going to be spending about 15,000, $16,000 a year of that salary to pay that down over the next 14 years. Um, so that’s going to take a lot of your, like a big chunk of change. Is there an emotional reason that you want to pay this down or is it just financial so that you don’t have to be responsible for it, um, when you’re going to your, when you’re FIRE.
I think it’s both. Like I think I detest having a loan out, especially it’s such a big number, like, you know, it was shared earlier that I have this net worth, but of like 300 and something thousand, but when, you know, so much of it is in my house and not in paper, I’m just like, let’s just pay off the house, which I think is an emotional response, um, and doesn’t add more to the paper. But, um, yeah, so I, I think it’s emotional and I also think that it would make me feel more free when I’m retired early potentially to, you know, not have to have a mortgage payment.
Yeah, completely understand. I think when you look at the math when it comes to whether you should pay down your mortgage early or not, it’s really does rest on interest rate and then we can look at emotions as well. With an interest rate of 3.1%, I believe that’s what it was, um, that’s quite low, especially if you’re going to compare that to putting money in the market and you have such a tight horizon for what you want that money like for how long you have to start putting money into the market. Um, I actually might recommend that you don’t pay down your mortgage super early. And maybe a little bit earlier than you were planning on it, but maybe not putting a lot of money towards it and instead redirecting that money towards, uh, not only your retirement accounts, but perhaps a brokerage account. And I think we’re going to get into that in a second here. So, just something to think about. If it is an emotional reason, I always say, you know, emotions trump finances. So I can understand why you do that. But it may be something just to take a little bit more of a reflection on, um, and perhaps continue to keep your mortgage, um, in, in later years.
Yeah, Amberly and I are both on team keep the mortgage, but because you have a 3.125% rate. I think we should say that so that because not everybody is looking at your spreadsheets. Uh, Amberly and I have them in front of us. And the 3.125% rate is not a rate that you are probably ever going to see again in your whole life. And you can always pay that off later. You can put the money into a high yield savings account while you’re making your minimum payments and investing the rest. Because the point that I have is once you pay off your mortgage, that money is locked into your house. Sure you can pull it out with a home equity line of credit, which is currently at like 8 or 9% interest. I don’t like paying 8 or 9% interest because I’m cheap. So I would want to put that in a high yield savings account so I have the option to take it and throw it all at the mortgage when I’m ready to retire and say, now I’m retiring mortgage-free. Or I can look at it and say, wow, I’ve got that money to pay the mortgage. I am going to instead invest it or, you know, I’ve grown all of my other buckets so I don’t really need to pay that off. You can, you have more options when you have a big bucket of money. So, uh, I like the idea of paying extra to a mortgage until I see that 3% rate.
Thanks. Yeah, I, I see that. And I, I started shifting. Like, with just within the last month because I’ve been like drinking your podcast. And I’m like, oh, I’ve heard you give that advice to someone else before. And I’m like, yeah, I do have a low interest rate and I don’t have a ton of cash availability. And I don’t want to do the middle class trap that I know you guys are very passionate about. So I appreciate your passion.
I have a second question because Mindy had asked me, when does she stop contributing to her 403B? Because that is your question. Here’s my other question for you. How much a year do you contribute to both your Roth IRA and your 403B? Do you know separately?
That’s a great question. I know I was contributing about 400 a paycheck to my 403B. Um, so that roughly if it that’s twice a month, so maybe about $10,000. But I’ve since upped it because I have my, um, my security money if you will. So I don’t I can now contribute more. So I’ve been contributing recently closer to $900 a month, uh sorry a paycheck to my 403B and some of it is post-tax or yeah. I think it’s called post-tax when I’ve already been taxed on the money. Um, it’s like a 403B Roth if that resonates. And then, uh, I contribute, I max out my Roth IRA. So.
7,000 a year for 2024, 2025.
Yes.
We have to take one final ad break. We’ll be back with more from Kat after this.
When you’re ready to start your business, Northwest Registered Agent helps you do more than just file paperwork. You get all the tools to build a real business identity from day one. A business address, website, phone number, operating agreement, free guides and more at no extra cost. Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the US with over 1500 corporate guides. These are real people who know your local laws and can help you in your business every step of the way. With Northwest, your business is set up to stand on its own from day one. That means your home address, personal email and phone number stay private. Don’t pay hundreds or thousands of dollars for what you can get from Northwest for free. Visit northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree and start using free resources to build something amazing. Get more with Northwest Registered Agent at northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree.
When the change in season hits, some people suddenly just want to declutter the garage, clean out the closets and get everything all organized. And that’s great. If that’s you, or if it’s not you, either way, let Monarch do the financial spring cleaning this year for you. One dashboard gets your entire financial life organized. No more clutter, no more mess, no more scattered logins, just accounts, investments, property, and more, all in one place. Another feature I love about Monarch is the weekly AI recap. It catches spending spikes before they become problems and flags big net worth shifts or upcoming expenses. It’s like having a quick personal check-in every week so nothing sneaks up on me. Get your first year of Monarch for half off, just 50 bucks with the promo code POCKETS. Use the code POCKETS at monarch.com to get your first year half-off at just $50. That’s 50% off your first year at monarch.com with the code POCKETS. P O C K E T S.
If you’ve been putting off life insurance, I get it. The old process was miserable. Phone calls with an agent, a nurse coming to your house for a blood draw, then waiting weeks to find out what you’d pay for. That friction is exactly why so many people who should have coverage don’t. Here’s what I believe. Most BP money listeners need term life. And the right move is to build a ladder. A few term policies of different lengths stacked together, so your coverage steps down as your mortgage shrinks and your kids get closer to being financially independent or you get closer to hitting your financial independence number. The thing that makes that practical now is Ethos, a platform that helps you find life insurance all 100% online. Same day coverage, no medical exam. You just answer a few health questions online. Up to $3 million in coverage, some policies as low as $30 a month. So building a two or three layer ladder that used to take a month of appointments is something you can knock out before your coffee gets cold. Get your free quote at ethos.com/bpmoney. That is E T H O S.com/bpmoney. Application times may vary and rates may vary.
You guys heard our recent episode with David Jackson and I’ll be honest, even as someone who lives and breathes this stuff, having a pro like David pressure test my plan was a game-changer. Domain Money is different because they don’t try to take over your accounts. They provide a flat fee service where a dedicated CFP analyzes your entire financial life with no stone left unturned. No hidden fees, no commissions, just clear, actionable strategy. Go to biggerpocketsmoney.com/cfp and book a free strategy session to see how they can help you reach FIRE faster. This is a promotion for Domain Money, a registered investment advisor with the SEC. BiggerPockets Money may receive compensation if you choose to work with Domain Money as a client. I, Scott Trench, am a current client of Domain Money and received non-cash compensation related to this promotional activity. This is not personalized investment advice. For the full disclosures, visit biggerpocketsmoney.com/cfp.
Thanks for sticking with us. I did some calculations for you because this is a really difficult question of when to stop contributing to your retirement accounts and instead move towards your brokerage accounts because you can use your retirement accounts, you can only use that after a certain time without penalty. And you know, it’s a 10% penalty. Sometimes it’s worth it to take the money out. Um, I know some some bloggers have done some uh, blogs about that and it’s kind of a wash sometimes. So, the other one is moving money into your brokerage account so you can use that money now and then rely on your retirement accounts later. So let’s just say, I’m going to say in 14 years you continue to use your Roth IRA as uh, you know, you funnel $7,000 into it. I’m sure it’ll go up over time for the amount you can do per year. But in 14 years you’re going to have 217,000 in it. At that point, you might say I am never going to contribute another dime to it, um, because you know, you’re no longer employed, um, you maybe don’t have earned income so you can’t. And you’re just going to let it sit there for the next 20 years, so then you’re 65 years old when you’ll actually start pulling in, but, you know, your, your Roth out. You’ll have $1 million. So, we know with the 4% rule, you’re going to have $40,000 a year at 65 just from your Roth IRA, not including your 403B. So with that and your 403B, you will have for sure hit your, your fine numbers at 65, right? I mean, I mean, way over, uh, in that moment or in that time. Because what you’re, I’m gonna do the same calculation, let’s just say with that lower amount, $10,000 a year for your 403B, in, at 65, you’re gonna have 1.1 million. So essentially, you’ll have $80,000 a year from those two accounts alone, not including a possible pension, um, or any social security work from work you do outside of teaching, um, in the future, if that’s what you decide to do, take on some sort of side job. Um, so when we’re thinking about that, it might mean you’re over-contributing if you continue to put money into it over the next 14 years and max those out. Um, I can’t say when you can stop, you know, contributing to your 403B. I think it’d be great for you some more homework to start doing some calculations to see what makes you feel comfortable to have at 65. And then that will show you when do you stop contributing to those accounts in the next, you know, within the next 14 years and start moving towards a brokerage account. Mindy, do you have thoughts on that?
I love this. I want to give a little bit more context to what you’re saying. Um, the rule of 72 is what where Amberly got this numbers, these numbers from. Essentially, the rule of 72 says that your investments at an 8% return will double every seven or eight years. So she has taken your numbers and just extrapolated that out. It is down and dirty math. It is absolutely not guaranteed. Past performance is not indicative of future gains. But it’s a great way to look at what your net worth will be in the future. And that’s stopping after a certain amount of time with your contributions. Um, she, she made mention that you can’t contribute to a Roth IRA if you don’t have earned income. You have a Roth 403B which makes my heart sing because that, all the Roth plans help you avoid the middle class trap. You can always access your contributions in a Roth IRA. You can’t access the gain. You can at age, is it 55 or 59 and a half?
59 and a half.
So you can, then you can start accessing the gains. You’re a teacher. I’m wondering if you have access to a 457 plan.
I don’t even know what that is.
That is another homework assignment for you to talk to your HR person about and just ask them, do we have a 457 plan? The 457 is a special plan, essentially for government employees like teachers who are, um, where you can put the current 401K, 403B contribution limits into your 403B and those same current ones into your 457 plan. So if you’ve, if the limit is 23,000, you can put 23 into your 457 and an additional 23 into your 403B for a grand total of 46,000. But wait, there’s more. Once you no longer work for that company, you can start accessing your 457 accounts with no penalties. If they’re a traditional 457, then you have to pay taxes on the money that you’re pulling out. But if they’re a Roth 457, you’ve already paid the taxes, you can just start pulling that money out. So with a partner who is uh, you know, perhaps able to help support you while you’re putting money into these 457 plans, or just look at you making $90,000 a year and your expenses aren’t that high, maybe you could max out both, or maybe you stop contributing to the 403B in favor of the 457 because when it comes time to pull money out, on the 403B, you’ll have to pay penalties, but on the 457, you won’t. So, that’s another homework assignment for you. Do you have a 457 and do you have a Roth 457?
Okay. Got it. Wrote down my homework. That’s teachers. Appreciate it. I love it. And you also want to know what your pension amount would be if you retire at 45 because I do think that you would get something. You definitely don’t get your full pension, but even if it’s half of what you would get at 55, that’s still a couple thousand dollars and who doesn’t like a couple of thousand dollars a month?
I’ll take it.
Yeah, exactly.
Can I ask a question?
Absolutely. This is your show. I, um, I appreciate it. I love, I love education. It’s just great. Um, and I promise you, what you guys tell me here, I am telling my students too. So they get a science research and financial freedom education at the same time from me. Um, they know I like getting off track sometimes. So this is good. Um, I was wondering if the 457, does, does a 457 have tax benefits also, I guess that’s the point of a 457 right, and that would be why it’s better than a brokerage account?
So it’s not better than a brokerage account, it’s different than a brokerage account. A traditional 457 is just like a traditional 403B or a traditional 401K in that you are reducing your taxable income by contributing to it. The Roth 457 plan doesn’t have the tax benefits. You’re not reducing your taxable income, but you’re paying tax now, putting it in the account, it grows tax free and it’s the one account that you can access when you separate from, from service from that company without having to hit an age limit, or an age threshold.
Okay. That makes sense. And the fact that Amberly, you said I would have about $2 million between my 403B and my Roth IRA was, is that with me still contributing the same amount every year until I hit 45 or is that, um, just from my current holdings?
Great question. What I calculated was you are doing your, um, Roth IRA and maxing it out at $7,000 a year with an 8% interest for the next 14 years. Then you are doing zero contributions for the next 20 to get you to 65. Though we can just do 59 if in a half, so 60 years old. So 15 years instead of 20, which is a different number, of course. Um, and you can, so that’s how we got to that calculation, right? Same thing with your 403B. It’s saying $10,000 a year. I’m not using that $900 a month every two weeks figure. I’m using the 400-ish. So saying you’re uh contributing about $10,000 a year for the next 14 years and then at 14 years that sum is never going to get contributed to again with an 8% interest rate.
Ok, got it.
Your rate of return may be different uh based on the government plans that you have to choose from. It just might not be the same as you have like if you’ve got a Fidelity account with your IRA, you can choose from anything, right? To invest in. But with government plans, I know sometimes they only have you limited uh selection for what you can invest in, so therefore your rate of return might be different than the general stock market depending on what you can invest in. I don’t know enough about um government plans since I don’t have one. I’ve just talked to a lot of government friends um and they have mentioned that sometimes their choices aren’t as robust as the general market.
I see. Yes. We have access to Vanguard and so I am, um, investing in like the general markets like the VOO and the VTSAX. Thank you to, um, the book. Oh my goodness. What’s the name of the book that everyone talks about?
The Simple Path to Wealth by J. L. Collins.
The Simple Path to Wealth. Thank you, Mindy. I was like, oh, that’s easy. I can just do that. Um, I like simple and easy because I have a very busy, um, life and I want to give all the time that I do have to my students. So thank you for the simplicity.
Perfect. Then using a seven or 8% rate of return will be perfect.
I think I mis-spoke earlier in the episode. The rule of 72, assuming a 7% interest rate, will double approximately every 10 years. Using an 8% interest, I’m sorry, 8% rate of return, a 7% rate of return is approximately every 10 years. An 8% rate of return is approximately every nine years, and uh 9% of return is, your money will double approximately every eight years and then if you get a whopping 10% which is awesome, it will take approximately seven years to double. So, it’s just it’s a great way to think about your future money. If we are in a crazy stock market where we had, I think one year we had a 22% rate of return, it’ll double every three years. Now we’re not going to hit three years of 22% returns. That would be super awesome. But that’s not a realistic number to think about. However, uh an eight or a 9% rate of return is absolutely doable. So I like to do 8% and do every nine years. Um, that’s just that’s a great way to think about it because if it, if it’s higher, great. You might have like that could be an average.
Okay. Okay. That makes sense.
One other question you had for us is, should I sell the stocks that I have that are in four specific stocks that have not been doing well? What is your reason for holding on to them?
The reason I’m holding on to them is because I know you’re not supposed to sell when low, you know. Um, but I don’t know anything other than that. So I don’t know when it would then make sense to sell because I don’t know what’s low and what’s not low other than when I went in. So I guess that would be what I would like it to get back to be at minimum. But.
What if it never does? What if this is the highest it’s ever going to be? Do you want to own these stocks now?
No, I think they make me feel uncomfortable because I don’t, it’s still it’s a good amount of my money that I have accessible because I don’t have a lot of money accessible if you will. Like I have the 60k overall in my savings for my 403B and Roth and I have, um, some savings in cash. But having like $13,000 in these stocks is that’s not, that’s like maybe about 13% of my money. So, um, it’s not nothing, you know, maybe if I had a much bigger net worth, I’d be like, yeah, it’s fine. I’ll just play with it. But I think because it’s a fairly sizable part of my wealth maybe, I should be doing something with it, um, in order to reach my goals. But I also don’t know because I don’t want to be silly and sell when low because that’s like rule number one, right? I don’t know.
Knowing what I know about these stocks, if I was in your position, I would sell them. They are $13,000. You have a 14 year timeline to reach financial independence and you don’t want to own these stocks. I would personally sell. You, uh, is this a, this is not a taxable event because you have lost money on these stocks, correct? They were, you bought them higher.
Correct.
So you’re, it’s you’re not going to be owing taxes on this. This is a a time to maybe chat with somebody who is a tax professional who can look at this and say, hey, this would be a great time to sell because you have some gains that you are going to put this up against. Um, but you don’t want to own this, these stocks anymore, then don’t own these stocks anymore. Amberly, what do you think?
One thing I always ask people whenever they’re feeling FOMO or some sort of, um, missing out on individual stocks, my first question is, Kat, did you have a plan on when to sell these stocks when you bought them?
No.
Great. So you went in blind, uh didn’t have a plan for what, what number it would hit to sell or what number it hit, um, of losing to sell. So therefore, you didn’t like, no plan means you’re running blind and that’s a really anxious and scary place to be when it comes to individual stocks. So, what I would say, as Mindy asked, um, if you were offered these stocks today, would you go buy them?
No.
All right, we got a lot of no’s here. So, I think, um, that probably means sell it, take the loss. It doesn’t mean you’re a failure. It doesn’t mean anything actually. It means that you tried something, you decided it wasn’t good. You got out before it got even lower or maybe even higher, it doesn’t really matter. And instead, you’re going to put your money to work somewhere else.
That makes a lot of sense. Yep. Thanks.
I love that. Ok, when I was reading off your numbers, I said, oh, you have $42,000 in cash. I’m going to talk about that again. And this is me talking about it. Why is this money sitting in cash?
Yes. I have 25,000, it’s actually in a CD. Um, it might be a little bit higher right now because of the interest it’s earned, maybe it’s like 26 or 27. So I can’t actually touch that for another like five months or something. Um, and then I have the loan that I said for $14,000 and I have about 14 or $15,000 in a high interest savings account that I’m just using to pay off the loan. So like when I took out this loan, I knew I had the money for it, but I figured I could just make a little bit of interest and that would, uh, make sense. So I might as well just take out a loan because it was zero interest. And I check that it gets paid every month because I do not want the 25% interest slapped on to, and the, like minimum payment, it’s wild to me that, you know, they show you the minimum payment, it’s like, I don’t know, a few hundred dollars, but then you’ll be paying it for like the rest of your life. So I’m like, yes, I do not want to keep this, but I might as well get another thousand to $2,000 off from just having it in a high-yield savings account.
Perfect. I love that answer because it shows you’ve been thinking about it. You’re not just doing something that you heard somebody say this one time. Um, I love this, the, these conscious choices based on, you know, education and thinking things through. The $25,000 in CD that you can’t touch for five months, do you have plans for that?
I do and I don’t. I don’t plan to spend it on anything specific, but because I own a home that was built in 1911, there’s just always something and it often is quite expensive. I will say, this is a brag moment, um, I built my own fence because they were asking for like $15,000 and I was like, I am not paying $15,000. So I learned how to do that. I built my own couch. I learned how to do that. Um, so I, you know, I try to get around not spending money where I don’t have to, but, um, like the piping system, our plumbing is not great. So I might have to spend some money on that, but I’m hoping I won’t need like a new car or anything for at least another 15, 20 years. If I’m like my mom, my car will last like another, my mom’s car is now almost like 30 years old, which is wild. So.
Yeah, no notes on that for me either. I think, you know, $25,000 is essentially a six-month, you know, buffer for you for an emergency fund. You can also use it towards your house, as you’re saying. So I’d probably keep something around there and having it in a CD or some sort of high-yield savings account is exactly where that should be. Um, whatever makes you feel comfortable in regards to the number of months for an emergency fund. Um, and you have a partner as well. So that’s really nice too, because you can always rely on them a little bit if you needed something or something happened to your job. Um, I have a question. Are you thinking of upping your income in any way by increasing tutoring hours, or are you looking to live more right now?
I will say my actions might be like contrary to how I feel. Um, because I’m constantly taking on new tutoring positions, um. I think part of that is it’s so easy. Like science is high in demand and I’m good at what I do, at least I would like to think I am. Um, but that being said, I feel like between what I, my position for work is like very demanding and tutoring on the weekend and I usually like do homework and prep before it and stuff, that takes a lot of my time. So, I would like to say I would lower tutoring, um, or I should do that for my mental health and sanity, which would probably make it that I wouldn’t have to retire early and yeah, I’m, I’m so like focused on the financial freedom. I know the value now of compounding interest thanks to you guys. So I’m like, yes, let’s just get there. I want that freedom feeling. But I also hear you guys talk about all the time that it’s the journey and not just this end number and it’s like really hard for me to absorb that when I feel like I have no free time and I’m like, just working for other people, but I know I’m part of my own problem. So yeah.
Completely understand as someone who loves to be busy, I get that. Um, so it sounds like for from what I’m hearing is that maybe increasing your income isn’t as necessary based on all the numbers that you have. Uh, it also might not be best based on your mental health and instead, um, it might be really great for you to do those calculations we were saying so you can see what um what time to stop contributing to your retirement accounts. Um, and you can maybe even increase your spending just a little bit now, um if you are looking at what you’re putting into um an actual brokerage account or a 557 as Mindy had said so you can access that money at 45. Um but you might even have a little wiggle room to go and do more fun things, uh as you’re saying you might want to do. What do you think, Mindy?
I think that we, Carl and I did it completely wrong. We plowed every dime we could into our retirement savings, into our brokerage accounts, into, we were busy, busy, busy all the time. We do the living flipping, so we would go, before kids, we would go to work, work eight hours, uh, in some cases, we were driving an hour each way to, to and from work. And then come home and work another five hours on the house, go to bed, get up and do it all again. We didn’t enjoy our life. And that is, uh, one of my biggest regrets because now I’m sitting on a nice FIRE number that is more than I need. And I could have been having so much more fun. Enjoy the journey because if it takes you, let’s say that you can crank it out and get there by age 45 or you can pull back just a touch, keep all the things that you love that mean something to you. And now you have to, you have to retire at 46. That’s a way better life. So I would encourage you to run your numbers, look at the different options that you personally have. I love the Roth account because you’re paying taxes now and it’s growing tax-free. You pull it out tax-free whenever you decide to pull it out. The Roth IRA, you can always pull out the contributions. I just, I love the freedom that it gives you and the flexibility. And what was that quote again? I realized what I really want is time freedom more than anything else. So I would just focus on what does that time freedom look like to you? If you could get away from the 40 hours of teaching or 38 hours of teaching per week, but then you could bring back tutoring for 10 hours a week and that covered your expenses, maybe that’s a great, a great trade off or maybe that doesn’t quite cover your expenses so you need to figure out another way to do it. Have you ever thought of making a science YouTube channel? Fun with Kat. Science fun with Kat. Like there’s so many ways to make money online. If you love talking about science, talk about science. I’m, you know, probably not gonna watch your show, but I will send my kids there. But I think you, you’ve got a great foundation. You’ve got an amazing foundation for somebody who’s 30 years old. You’ve got a great foundation and I don’t see your goal of 45 or 45-ish to be something that’s like, oh my goodness, that’s never going to happen. I can see that as absolutely happening. Maybe it doesn’t happen at 45. Maybe it happens at 46 or 47. That’s still way lower than 65. So you have all that time to go and enjoy your life with no job.
Thank you for spending so much time chatting with me today and for the resources. Um, I think definitely playing with the numbers will be fun and it’s not about like even all of this for me, it’s not about exactly like stopping working at 45. Like I can’t even envision myself not doing anything. Um, as I feel like a lot of people in the FIRE community, not everyone, but a lot of people kind of don’t exactly stop everything when they do FIRE. Um, I think I’ll always be doing something. So I would probably have more of a Barista FIRE if not for just, you know, being engaged with my brain. Um, and you know, too much time by myself, I think I would lose my mind if I’m being honest. But um, yeah, it’s cool to know kind of where I’m at with things and what might be possible. And I’m definitely nowhere near having $425,000 invested. So, but I hear you on saying that, you know, what I want in life is more time and I’m already choosing not to do that for myself. So maybe if I change that, it would just make things more enjoyable. So.
If you’re thinking about, oh, I’m not sure what I would do in retirement, start a bucket list.
Well, Kat, any other questions for us?
I think you guys answered all my questions. Um, thank you so much for your time and thoughts and this was so fun. I was so excited to meet you and you’re here, you’re real people. It’s great.
Alright, Kat, I really appreciate your time today. Thank you so much for coming on and sharing your numbers with us and we will talk to you soon. Alright Amberly, that was a super fun episode with Kat. What did you think of the show?
Well, she’s super smart and is already thinking about her future and I just love that she’s not just like thinking about her future, but she’s thinking about her past and what her parents were like and how she’s like today. And and like you mentioned in the episode, what she wants to do with her life at 45, she should start doing today. And I think that she’s in such a great position to start funneling money towards her future, but also like really focusing on maybe doing some fun things. What do you think?
One of the best things that she is doing is keeping her expenses low. And that allows her so much opportunity. She’s got the opportunity to contribute to these other accounts. She’s got the opportunity to max out a Roth IRA, which I hope that she does. She’s got the opportunity to add in a little bit of fun spending because the delta between what she’s spending on her life and what she’s making is so vast. So, you know, I want to encourage people to keep everything in that means something to them. If you’ve got, you know, you want to have breakfast every Monday with your daughter, then have breakfast every Monday with your daughter, like breakfast out. If you want to have a date every Friday night with your partner, then have a date every Friday night with your partner. Don’t cut things out in the the name of, I want to get to FIRE as fast as possible because let me tell you, I did and it’s not all that fun. The journey kind of stinks. So, uh, don’t do it like me, be like Amberly, be like Kat will be soon. And keep the fun stuff in your life.
My only concern for her is this pension. You know, we don’t know enough about pensions to give all that much, uh, information for her, but retiring at 45 when, you know, a pension is 50% at 55. I’m really curious what that’s going to look like for her. And she’ll be taken care of with, um, you know, the investing that she’s doing. I’m just so curious. I hope she gets back to us about what that actually is going to look like for her if she were to leave work at 45. And hopefully all that, um, time and energy she’s spent, you know, contributing towards it does give her some sort of payback.
Yes, I hope it does. She has, you know, 14 years to figure it out. And perhaps in 14 years, she decides, you know what? It is worth it for me to stay an extra 10 years and get that much more in my pension. Maybe she has lost all of these things in her life that are making her feel so pressured with her time, and now she truly enjoys only teaching or teaching and tutoring and, you know, she’s lost other things, and we’ll continue on. That’s what’s so great about the beginning of the FIRE journey, you have a big horizon. I would encourage her to continue to revisit her numbers, either quarterly or annually, just to see where she is on track. Um, I would also encourage her and anybody else listening, not to get too bogged down with dips. We are in a period of economic uncertainty right now. The stock market is reacting rather volatilely, up, down, up, down. It’s kind of a roller coaster. So if that gives you a lot of nerves, take a step back and don’t look for a while. You know, look again in a month, look again at the end of next quarter. Um, but keep an eye on your numbers to see where you’re going, watch how they are progressing and how you like your life. If you don’t like your life and your numbers keep going up, make some changes.
I agree with that completely.
Um, thanks, Mindy. That’s, that’s a really great, uh, summation.
Alright, Amberly, should we get out of here?
Let’s do it. Bye-bye.
Alright, that wraps up this episode of the BiggerPockets Money podcast. I truly love these conversations with people who have retired before it was cool, before anybody wrote a blog post about it. And I love Diana’s story. Thank you so much for joining me. My name is Mindy Jensen, saying out I zoom Bloom.
When you’re ready to start your business, Northwest Registered Agent helps you do more than just file paperwork. You get all the tools to build a real business identity from day one. A business address, website, phone number, operating agreement, free guides and more at no extra cost. Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the US with over 1500 corporate guides. These are real people who know your local laws and can help you in your business every step of the way. With Northwest, your business is set up to stand on its own from day one. That means your home address, personal email and phone number stay private. Don’t pay hundreds or thousands of dollars for what you can get from Northwest for free. Visit northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree and start using free resources to build something amazing. Get more with Northwest Registered Agent at northwestregisteredagent.com/moneyfree.
