BiggerPockets Money Podcast

$1.2M Invested: Is It Safe for One Spouse to Quit Working?

BiggerPockets Money Podcast
BiggerPockets Money Podcast
$1.2M Invested: Is It Safe for One Spouse to Quit Working?
Loading
/

Show Notes

Could one spouse quit a high-paying job without putting the family’s financial independence at risk? Madison Sharick, a CFA and CFP at Nectarine, joins Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench to work through a case study of a family with $1.2 million invested, two kids, and $90,000 in annual spending. They explore how leaving a job affects the path to FIRE, whether portfolio withdrawals can bridge the income gap, and how starting a business changes the financial picture. Plus, they break down how much cash to keep on hand, why healthcare costs matter, and when a taxable brokerage account may be worth prioritizing over tax advantages. Before you quit your job, here’s what you need to consider.

To go beyond the podcast:

Connect with Madison Sharick:

  • Instagram: @MadiManagesMoney

We believe financial independence is attainable for anyone no matter when or where you’re starting. Let’s get your financial house in order!

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript

Read Full Transcript

📄 Full Episode Transcript

Mindy Jensen: What happens when one spouse wants to quit their job, but you’re both still working towards financial independence? Can you make it work on one income, or will it push your FI date out years later? Hello, hello, hello, and welcome to the BiggerPockets Money Podcast. My name is Mindy Jensen, and with me as always is my loves-for-one-spouse-to-quit co-host, Scott Trench.

Scott Trench: Thanks, Mindy. We’re hoping that this episode will get a really good Wi-Fi reception here today. We’re bringing on Madison Sharick, a CFA and CFP at Nectarine, to break down how to run the numbers and what you can adjust to make leaving work a reality without derailing your financial future. Nectarine is a podcast partner with us here at BiggerPockets Money, and we may receive financial compensation if you choose to work with a CFP professional that you find at nectarine.com. With that, Madison, welcome to the BiggerPockets Money Podcast.

Madison Sharick: Thank you for having me.

Scott Trench: Awesome. So you did some really great work here in preparing us to set the stage, and I think that the way I should interpret this is that a common type of client, like an aggregation, anonymized aggregation of types of people you work with, might look something like this case study we’ve prepared, right? Both are 42. There are 2 kids. There’s $1.2 million invested, excluding the primary residence. They’re doing great. One spouse earns $150,000, the other earns $75,000, for a total of $225,000 in pre-tax income, and they currently spend $90,000 a year. So their childcare expenses are starting to roll off as their kids are potentially going into public school, but they’re not quite there yet. And one spouse wants to quit their job. They’re wondering if they can still reach financial independence on a single income while targeting about $125,000 in retirement spending, a higher level of spending than they have now. Is that a typical situation that you come in with? Is that how I should understand that?

Madison Sharick: Definitely. And I think what makes it so typical is those years whenever you have kids, especially younger kids, and both spouses are working. People will refer to this as the messy middle. It is oftentimes the point in time in your life where somebody might actually need to back off or take more time in the home to do work there.

Scott Trench: Awesome. And what’s the typical question someone like this comes to you with?

Madison Sharick: So usually people are asking, one, am I still on track for what I would call a normal retirement age, around 60 plus? And then the second question is, am I still on track for early retirement? So assuming we’re on normal track, can we still do early retirement? And I think that will probably be a pretty interesting discussion for today.

Scott Trench: So take it away. Who are they? What is your instinctive response to situations like this?

Madison Sharick: Yeah, so I think it depends on who wants to step back from work. Now we have the case that is a little bit more of a layup, I’ll call it. So if the spouse who is the higher-earning spouse plans to stay at work, and the lower-earning spouse, who is earning like $75,000, peels off of work, I ran some numbers—they’re already close to financial independence. So, you know, that’s, I think, a good baseline to start with, that they’re already on track for retirement at, I calculated, around like 60, 61, even if they don’t add more money to their accounts. So I think they’re already, table stakes of being on track for a normal retirement date without contributing more to accounts. I think that’s a comfortable thing to know as you’re going into potentially a big life change for yourself.

Scott Trench: Yeah, it makes sense, right? We’re going to get 3 doublings, give or take, you know, maybe a little less than 3 doublings of $1.2 million. And so that gives you what, $2.4, $4.8?

Mindy Jensen: $9.6.

Scott Trench: $9.6. Yeah. So that should be way more than enough for traditional retirement. How do you think about that in the context of Coast FI? Are they way past Coast FI? Can I separate assets and call this chunk my Coast FI number?

Madison Sharick: I think they could, depending on what they spend in retirement. This is always the big what-if for people, and it’s really hard to wrap your arms around what will we actually spend. So in this case study, there are folks who plan to spend more in retirement than they necessarily are today, which not everyone does in real life, but for planning purposes, this is oftentimes what people want to see. So I think they were planning to spend like $125,000 in retirement. So spending that number, they’re not way ahead. If they plan to spend more like $90,000, they’re more so, I would say, at Coast FI at a full retirement age of maybe mid-50s. That would be the territory where maybe we can carve off a chunk of this, identify it as the money that they are, air quotes, protecting to coast. It’s like their coast bucket. And then they have a chunk of money that they could plan to spend in the meantime, assuming it’s liquid and not in something like a retirement account.

Scott Trench: It’s almost too easy to say, hey, if you have $1.2 million invested at 40 and you continue to earn more than you spend, then you’re going to be fine. Like, yes, you can do this. That seems like a pretty, you know, like you said, layup answer. I would love to dive into a harder problem that I think faces some component of folks, to explore this issue in a more deeply intellectual way. When we have the $75,000 earner in a household as the one who keeps their job, and our $150,000 earner stops—maybe they go start a business, maybe they just take a break for a while, or whatever—now we’re actually burning money, and we’re burning a lot of money. We’re burning more than the $15,000 implied spread there, because we’ve got taxes. We presumably have health insurance coming out of that paycheck. We’ve got any other deferrals, taxes including FICA, that are withheld. And so maybe that $75,000 headline salary actually is closer to $50,000 to $55,000 in net cash hitting this household’s bank account. And now we’ve got a question. Now we’ve got a spread of almost $35,000, $40,000 to cover each year. And Coast FI is kind of a tricky circular reference, right? You’re Coast FI if you have a certain amount of money and you don’t touch it, but if you begin withdrawing on it, you’re not Coast FI anymore. So how would you coach somebody in a situation like that, in terms of thinking about whether they have some portion of that $1.2 million that they have invested as accessible for them to float this Coast FI decision?

Madison Sharick: So I think there are 2 ways we can think of this. One, kind of like we talked about before, we can carve off a piece that we would consider in play for them to spend in the interim. So whatever would be the amount that they would need to, what I would say, maintain their Coast FI status, leave that in places like retirement accounts, consider it untouchable, access other funds in the meantime. Another way we could approach it is by spending a percentage of your overall assets now. So it’s kind of like dipping a little bit early into the 4% rule, and I’ll give you a relatively safe percentage to use. So if you withdraw 2% or less per year from your portfolios, that’s an extremely safe withdrawal rate. So the 4% rule in and of itself is designed to be conservative. There have never really been portfolios that, whenever you run projections on them, that they bonk, so to speak, if you spend less than 2% per year from your investments.

Scott Trench: It would be very difficult to disagree with that statement, right? A 2% withdrawal rate is absurdly safe. But the bet in Coast FI is that I’m going to allow that portfolio to compound at the return assumption that I plug into the calculator. And if I’m withdrawing 2% from that portfolio, then I’ve got to reduce my return assumptions for Coast FI by a corresponding amount, or maybe even do some different math to talk about withdrawal sequencing instead of just the compound annual growth rate I’m assuming. How do I think about that? Am I still Coast FI if I’m withdrawing even 2% or 1%?

Madison Sharick: It depends. Like you’re saying, Coast FI, there are so many assumptions that go into this. The younger you are, the better it works. The more return you get, the better it works. You can’t control things like investment returns. What I can tell you, though, with this couple that we’re looking at, when I run their numbers, and I’m running Coast FI numbers anyway, and I’m getting to a full retirement age, you know, early 60s without contributing more to accounts, I would be reluctant to have them go for a long period of time where they are making substantial withdrawals from their assets. In that case, you’re starting to look at a full retirement age that’s getting pushed out further and further. The older that gets, the riskier it gets. You don’t want to commit to working beyond a point where you might not be able to do so in the future.

Scott Trench: I guess if I’m hearing this right, I’m this couple, I’m coming to you, and my frustration is, I’m a millionaire and I own my home. Why can’t I get off the treadmill right now? Why am I still only 5 years, a decade, at least from FI with what is not a crazy level of spending here? I’m spending perhaps the median for a household in the Denver area, but I’m stuck. I can’t access this. And I kind of have these 2 hard choices. One is, do I bump my Coast FI number up? Do I need more so I can withdraw 2% from the overall portfolio? Do I just spend dividends? That’s probably floating my mind. I don’t know if there’s a real, if there’s an academic answer to that. Do I set aside $800,000 and call that my Coast FI number, and then begin distributing the withdrawals at 4% from the $400,000 pile remaining? Those are answers that come into my mind here. I think that the core frustration here is it feels like by getting to the halfway point, my quality of life doesn’t actually change the way that it seems like it ought to.

Mindy Jensen: Why does it have to change? You’re halfway there. You’re not all the way there. And it’s the slog. It’s the messy middle. It’s, I’ve been doing it for a while, I want to have a different life. You’re still doing really great to have this $1.2 million at the age of 42. You’re still on the path to being financially independent at some point in the future, and that’s really awesome. But if you want to quit your job now, you’re going to have different choices. You’re going to have different options available to you because you’ve chosen a different path. And I can understand why somebody who is making $150,000 a year might be burned out. They’ve got a job that’s really stressful. Maybe they really don’t like their boss. I would want them to really articulate why they want to leave, why they think they can leave. And also, I would want to look at their spending and see if there are any levers that they can pull in their spending to reduce their spending. Just because they’re spending $90,000 now doesn’t mean that they have to continue spending $90,000. But, Madison, you said if they take out 2%, that’s a pretty safe number. 2% is $24,000. So add that on top of the $55,000 that they’re bringing home, and that’s still only $79,000. That’s a lot less of a gap, but is that $11,000 that they’re missing out on with their $90,000 in spend?

Madison Sharick: So if we think about this from the standpoint of their take-home pay, what they’re netting, compare the difference of what they have to go into their portfolios to get—maybe let’s think about it that way and see what they’re actually going to need during this time. So if they’re earning $75,000, take-home pay is going to be somewhere between $60,000 to $62,000 or so. I’m not taking out things like health insurance premiums yet, but I am considering things like FICA tax, federal income tax. And then I ran numbers like where I live—I live in Pennsylvania, we have a 3% state tax rate. So depending on where you live, you might have state taxes, you might not. It’s a good average to use. So you’re getting somewhere between $60,000 to $62,000 take-home. The difference between $90,000 and that $62,000, we’ll call it, is what you have to go get from your portfolios.

Mindy Jensen: Okay, I was doing numbers on $55,000, so $62,000 was a better jump. If we pull out that 2%, that’s the $24,000, that on top of the $60,000, that’s $84,000. The difference between $90,000 and $84,000 is a lot better.

Madison Sharick: For sure. And remember, if you’re pulling this from a place like a brokerage account, taxes from a brokerage account tend to be less bad than what people fear. Remember, you’re only paying tax on the price growth. For most people, as long as it’s long-term capital gain, you’re paying a 15% rate on that. So I would actually argue taxes on that amount you’re going into the portfolio to get are kind of a rounding error for these numbers. So we’re getting close to that 2% threshold that I mentioned. Mindy, you mentioned trimming spending a bit—I don’t like to overly plan for trimming spending, because I do think it’s challenging to do sometimes in real life, especially if you have fixed costs, younger kids, things like that. These numbers are pretty close, though. They might be able to make it meet and still stay in that 2% range.

Mindy Jensen: Okay, so you think that this could be doable for the higher earner to leave their job and the lower earner to continue working, continue to support the family. What is this going to do to their financial independence timeline if the higher earner leaves their job?

Madison Sharick: I would say best case scenario, they are retiring in their early 60s. So I’m running numbers with relatively conservative growth rates. I’m using a 5 to 6% real growth rate, an investment growth rate that’s already factoring in things like inflation, getting to early 60s, but they’re also using bits as they go. So I’m probably being conservative with my growth rates, but they’re using bits. They’re probably getting close to like early 60s at best. I’d think about this from a practical standpoint. If this is a person who is taking time off of work, especially if you have younger kids, more often than not, that person is not staying retired forever, right? So the chances they go back to work, or maybe costs do come down in the future when kids are out of the house, I like their chances of eventually being able to contribute to investment portfolios again.

Mindy Jensen: Yeah, because not only are they withdrawing from what’s already put aside for retirement, but they’re also not able to contribute pretty much anything to their retirement if the higher earner leaves. I don’t want to be all doom and gloom, but I want somebody who is in this position to understand that this could be the scenario. This could push your retirement date back, and maybe that’s worth it, but I don’t want them to reach age 55, when they thought they’d be able to retire, and be like, oh, we’re nowhere close now because we’ve been pulling out. Don’t make this decision until you run the numbers in all the different scenarios.

Scott Trench: Let’s talk about what I think is a much more common problem for a household of this type, at least in my experience, and I think you will agree with me. The higher income earner does not want to stop working entirely. They want to go into some kind of self-employment or business ownership endeavor. So maybe they want to get their real estate agent license. Maybe they want to become a certified financial planner, like yourself, and do exactly what you’ve done here, Madison, and work with clients in the FI community. Maybe they want to do loans. I talked to a real estate investor who worked a corporate job and wanted to leave and become a lender. That is, in my experience, much more common as a desire for the higher income earner. And there’s still a ton of fear and uncertainty, and rightfully so, because we’re leaving the breadwinner job in the household. And now we’re going to go and start something where the income could be zero or very low, or even maybe lose money if there’s an acquisition or a loan taken out to buy a business or something like that. Is that the right way to frame this? Is that more common in the scenario where the higher income earner wants to leave work for you?

Madison Sharick: Yeah, I think that’s a fair way to frame it. Yeah, especially for folks this age. Your 30s, your 40s—again, rarely are people saying, my spouse is going to continue working until they’re in their 60s, and I’m really retired, though, and I’m just not doing anything until the next 2 decades. So yeah, this happens a lot, where especially I think folks in tech or other highly technical fields, people will often leave their current jobs and then do some form of consulting relevant to that skill thereafter. I don’t want to say it’s a low-risk way to do it, but having your spouse continue with a relatively steady income, even if it’s less than what yours is, and then also provide access to things like ongoing health insurance, that really reduces the risk of leaving work and taking on a venture like this.

Scott Trench: Let’s take this position and let’s tweak it in a couple of ways. In what circumstances would you say, please don’t quit your job, this is a terrible idea for a household of this type? And in which situation would you say, yeah, you definitely should do this, or this makes a lot of sense if that’s what your heart’s set on? How would you make that determination when advising a potential client in variations of our starting case study here?

Madison Sharick: So things I think about are: what access to liquidity do you currently have? Do you have a robust pool of either brokerage or high-yield savings type of assets, so that, let’s say things don’t go as planned, you have access to funds like that? Or if it takes longer to get up and running and profitable than what you anticipated, you have savings on hand. So that’s one thing to think about. I think when things go wrong, or when people fail, it’s not necessarily because the business won’t work. It’s just that they didn’t have enough runway and time to make it work. So that really helps. The other thing I would say is, whenever you are leaving a job and then continuing self-employment work in a related field, it seems like those folks do have a good idea of how profitable it will be and what you can actually make with those skills.

Scott Trench: What’s an example of a situation where you’re like, this is definitely not going to work? And what’s one where, hey, this was related enough for it to work? Can you give us some more concrete evidence behind that point?

Madison Sharick: Think of this at a very basic level. When you’re going to college and choosing a major, what are the fields that tend to be more profitable ones? Usually businesses in those fields, folks do tend to, especially if they worked in it already, make money continuing to do that. If you’re leaving work and you’re starting a sourdough bread business, that’s going to be more of like a lifestyle. You’re probably not gonna make a ton of money.

Scott Trench: Not gonna be rolling in the dough.

Madison Sharick: Probably not gonna be rolling in the dough. Pizza shop, sourdough, you’re probably not rolling in the dough. Yep.

Scott Trench: Okay, awesome. And then walk us through, even in the scenarios where there’s like a reason, if you’ve never been in the baking business and you go into it, you’re going to be in for a rude wake-up call. That makes perfect sense to me, and I think a lot of people are very overly optimistic in that regard. Like, for example, there was this big thing about the laundromat. Remember that? The laundromat on social media the last few years. Buy a laundromat, you’re going to do great. Buy a boring business from a baby boomer and babysit some workers who won’t show up on time in the contracting services arena, and you’re going to make a bajillion dollars. I, you know, like, okay, sure, it’s possible, it’s there, but you’re going to be in for a little bit of a wake-up call compared with you’re a software engineer and you go into software engineering consulting, or begin taking clients where you manage their websites. There’s a very different probability of success in those types of fields.

Madison Sharick: I’ve gotten a lot of people who are into like the buy-a-business type of thing, they’re interested in doing that, and like you’re saying, they’re not always profitable. And even if you purchase something that is profitable, you are outlaying a chunk of capital in order to do that. I think that’s another distinguishing factor of taking more risk versus less risk. Anytime you’re outlaying a chunk of money to purchase something, it’s always going to be riskier than if you are doing consulting and you have really low overhead when you’re doing so.

Scott Trench: There’s also certain personality types that are suited to certain types of businesses here. So you may not like it if you’re used to managing $150,000, $200,000-a-year executives, and then you’re all of a sudden managing employees who have trouble showing up on time and doing those types of things. That’s the reality of some different types of businesses at different wages and skill levels. And I think people do not realize that and are in for a huge wake-up call. I have certain friends that are suited to both, for example, who I’ve been like, yeah, you should definitely do this, and you should definitely not do this over that time period. But I think that’s a great sanity check — your spouse probably has a really good opinion on that if you’re thinking about this, and maybe a good one to bring to a CFP as well if you’re thinking about one of these huge lifestyle changes and getting some guidance on which direction to go.

Madison Sharick: Yeah, I think there’s something to be said about trading one type of stress for another type of stress. I think this is common in the FI community. It’s like people talk about this all the time. Like, what are you trying to get away from? You’re trying to leave a stressful job and then do something else afterwards, or be retired afterwards. If you’re switching one stressful job to another potentially stressful job — have you ever heard of the saying, “everywhere I go, there I am”?

Mindy Jensen: Yeah.

Madison Sharick: It’s probably gonna level out to feeling similar.

Scott Trench: You’ve had many clients that have gone on to leave their high-income corporate job and be successful in a version of what we’re talking about here, right?

Madison Sharick: Yeah, I’ve had people do everything across the spectrum between full early retirement, starting new businesses, spending time with kids. That’s another common one, where you might not know what the next thing is, but you’re really focused on the next 5 years or so. Your spouse continues to work, and you take off for a period of time.

Scott Trench: Just one more thing on the business piece here. This snippet of clients who have been successful in going into business — how long does it take them usually? How does the first year go? How does year 3 go? What is the trajectory like for most of the people who go down this route?

Madison Sharick: It depends on the type of business, but it’s usually longer than what people guess to actually get to the point of where you are profitable at the level that you thought you would be. If I had to give you a number, we’re looking at like 3 years or so until you are earning at a level that you really guessed that you’d be, what you hoped you’d be earning anyway.

Scott Trench: And is that usually more or less than they were making at a W-2?

Madison Sharick: Oh gosh, it depends. Oftentimes people leave jobs, and when I say the word “hope,” they’re hoping to make just as much or more at that time. There are plenty of people who leave jobs though, and their intent is not to fully replace their income. They might be switching into something that is more of like lower-stakes work, or like lifestyle work — that’s a lower bar to clear, right? It totally depends on the field someone is going into. Now, I’ll say this: if you are comparing your income in, let’s say, work-optionality or early-retirement years, if you’re comparing that to your previous W-2 pay and you don’t feel good about how it compares — it’s less than what you earned before — just remember, anytime that you were earning money in early retirement, it’s preventing you from dipping into your portfolio at that time. So I think of what you earn at that time in the context of the 4% rule, less so as a comparison to what you earned before.

Scott Trench: Is that how your clients perceive it?

Madison Sharick: They do after a little bit of coaching. I think it makes them feel better. Think about it — every dollar that you earn, yes, there’s taxes in that, but every dollar that you earn is preventing you from dipping into your portfolio at that time. So it’s more impactful than it even was when you were earning and stuffing into accounts.

Scott Trench: The dream is, “I’m going to leave my job and I’m going to make about what I made while I was working full-time, with way less effort and a way more flexible schedule, within a year or two.” You’re saying push that timeline out to 3 years — is that kind of the answer?

Madison Sharick: I think that’s a good summary. Yeah.

Scott Trench: Okay, so we’ve got that. How bad is the first year then? How should I plan my liquidity and withdrawals around what is surely going to be the hardest one? Do I usually go negative in the first year, or is it just very barely positive — like, how does that go?

Madison Sharick: Once you get done with your identity crisis during that first year after you’ve left your full-time job and start thinking about using assets, it’s going to depend on where you have funds. Hopefully, if this is something that you planned ahead for, you were able to store some like in cash, or I would say more stable types of investments. You don’t want to keep all of your funds in stock market index funds if you need them relatively soon. Relatively soon, to me, is within 2 years or less. You should start shifting those assets over to cash or bonds at that time — you want it to be relatively stable for you. Going back to our little case study that we have here, these folks who are in their early 40s — they’re 42, they have $1.2 million in assets. Usually people who are coming to me with a profile like this, they do have at least some in places like taxable brokerage assets. It’s not fully in retirement accounts, but you can get yourself into a little bit of a bind if you saved absolutely everything into retirement accounts.

Scott Trench: Yep. That’s what formerly was called the middle-class trap issue here, the deferral dilemma, right? And where it is, I’m like, oh, it doesn’t exist if you’re — because you’re not FI yet. Well, sure. If you’re truly FI and you stop working, both parties, and you begin withdrawing, there’s ways out of this thing. But this is the more acute issue — it’s like, I don’t feel like I have any options because I’m not liquid right now and I can’t stop working. Because then if I stop working and I have to withdraw from my 401(k), I’m going to pay taxes on that, on top of my liquidity crunch. I’m going to need more dollars withdrawn to pay the taxes on those. That begins to get very scary very quickly. I’m sure it can be overcome to various degrees, but that’s the feeling of, “why the heck am I a millionaire, a liquid millionaire, and yet I cannot stop this high-paying job and actually enjoy Tuesday afternoon with my kiddo.” That’s the frustration that I think is very acute to a small fraction of people in the FI community, on the cusp of, or well into, the FI journey but not quite to the finish line yet. I think the offset to that is to build up some after-tax position — build it up in your brokerage account. And if you agree with that premise, the time to do that is early in your career, maybe right after you get married, but in the early part of the career when you’re in the lower tax brackets — the 10% or the 12% federal tax bracket — that’s the time to build up the brokerage, in my opinion. Because it gets harder and harder to justify that when you’re in the 22%, 24%, or even higher tax brackets — then the deferral math becomes overwhelming for many people, all but the people pursuing Fat FIRE, or, you know, the very high end of Chubby FIRE.

Madison Sharick: For what I would say are relatively high earners, usually I give people a pecking order to work down whenever you’re contributing to accounts. So Scott, everything you’re saying I agree with and it holds. When you’re younger, that can be a good time to build brokerage assets. A lot of times people also contribute to Roth at that time too, just because from a tax standpoint, it’s the golden years for creating Roth assets. If we flash forward to this period of time where you’re a high earner, you’re stressed, is before you would leave a job or take a sabbatical. The pecking order that I think about is still filling up your tax-advantaged accounts, but if you have extra, brokerage is where you stuff it. You have a certain amount of cash you should keep on hand, so your emergency fund, routine ins and outs of checking — get in a habit of anything extra gets scooped over to brokerage. And I would even go as far as recommending that as an automatic contribution. Pay yourself first, and make sure that you’re storing your brokerage assets so it’s ready for something like a sabbatical.

Scott Trench: I just prefer setting up that problem in the early years, so you don’t have to do that less tax-efficient thing later on. But if you’re already there, then I think you got to do exactly what you said.

Madison Sharick: What I think of myself in my 20s, and especially before I had kids — like, I knew what financial independence was. I’ve been into this stuff in the FI community since I was, you know, in my 20s. I don’t want to say I didn’t buy into it, but I didn’t see needing early retirement for myself because I was a career gal. I was full send into this — I was gonna be a corporate executive. That was the plan. Things changed a lot once I had kids. I got to like 30 or so, and it’s just really hard to know that when you were in your 20s. I think anyone who is in their 20s and listening to Scott’s advice — it’s probably sage words to plan ahead in that way.

Scott Trench: I think that the kids thing in particular confounds all this for our household too. This is actually core to the discussion here. This household is stuck because they’re a Denver-based household with a family of 4, ages 35 to 44, a couple with kids, and they’re spending $8,300 a month, or about $100,000 annually, right? That’s the core problem here. When their kids leave the house and they become a 2-person household, ages 55 to 64, a couple with no kids, their spending drops by almost $23,000 per year — at the very time when you most want access to these funds and are at your peak, you know, your peak earnings potential, or, you know, at then-peak earnings potential is probably the right way to put it. That’s also the time when you’re going to want to spend the most in inflation-adjusted dollars. I think this is a big trap. I think this is exactly what a lot of people do. In your case study, you said their retirement spending target is $125,000 per year. I always adjust everything for inflation, so I’m assuming that’s — they want to spend $125,000 of 2026 dollars in retirement. And that would mean that their retirement spend is going to put them into the top quintile, into the top 20th percentile, for households of that type — approaching that, assuming that there’s no FICA, they’re going to be somewhere in that ballpark here, of $140,000-ish, $125,000, $140,000 a year, in the Denver area. And I think that’s a problematic assumption. That’s a challenge for the FI community — why is that your peak earning years in your model? Why are you planning on and assuming that? Is that margin of safety, or is that your actual intent? Because if it’s margin of safety, then we need to inflate all of our numbers. But if that’s actually what I want, I think that’s not how humans want to live their lives. I think we want to spend the most when our kids are young and in the house, relatively speaking, and are fine dropping a little bit in retirement, you know, at an older age. So I don’t know, is that driving any of this? I’m not challenging that people come to you with that goal the way you framed it in the case study you presented to us, but I am challenging whether that’s the right answer, the right goal in the first place for this household.

Madison Sharick: Do you mean to plan? You’re not sure it’s the right goal to necessarily plan to spend more when they’re in retirement. You’re saying really that should be now.

Scott Trench: Well, yeah — I’m going to spend $90,000 now and $125,000 in retirement. That’s what this household is telling you. Why is that your goal? Why is it not $125,000 now and $90,000 in retirement, or $90,000 now and something less in retirement?

Madison Sharick: I think that’s a really good question and a challenge to this. And I find that oftentimes people want to conservatively Frankenstein numbers — that’s what I’ll call it. So it’s not even necessarily that they have $125,000 and they have earmarked the things that they want to use it for. They just want to know, like, “do I have robust enough assets that even if I have to spend $125,000 when I can no longer go back to work, will that be available to me?” I think it’s probably too much based on their spending today. You know, hearing things like childcare costs could come out eventually, the kids are going to be out of the house, things like that. I’d also remember, though, we don’t have things like college costs for the kids explicitly itemized here. We’re also not necessarily including a specific budget for healthcare in retirement, and things like long-term care too. I often find if somebody’s running numbers on their own versus if I do detailed projections in software, one of the biggest differences is what I’m assuming you have to pay for long-term care, and then healthcare throughout your life. I said conservatively Frankenstein — I don’t think it hurts to project to spend more though, given how young they are and how much further they have to go in their lives.

Scott Trench: Got it. So what do you think is the most important thing to talk about next for this household? Healthcare should be covered in the immediate future by the remaining spouse’s work, although I’d argue that healthcare is the biggest known unknown. Most people are not sure exactly how to do that, but we can quantify that now with the current law, at least. But what do you think is the next most important issue for them to consider?

Madison Sharick: I think they’re going to be pretty acute things. So, planning for where you’re pulling funds from over the next several years — if a client came to me with this, we could look at your brokerage account, literally go into it, identify which positions that we would sell so that it’s tax efficient in order to do so. Having the funds available to you in a liquid place, I think, is the biggest question though. Let’s say they don’t have liquid funds in like a savings account or brokerage account — for a client this young, I would be reluctant to do things like, you know, 72(t). You would have to really twist my arm to access Roth principal and really do any of the touching of retirement accounts. I’d hope on a call together, we’d be looking at how to efficiently use brokerage and savings account assets. That’s my wish for them.

Mindy Jensen: Just because somebody wants to quit doesn’t mean that this is the right time for them to quit. I mean, you look at all of these different scenarios and all of these different parts that make up your finances, and just because you want to quit doesn’t mean that — you know what, maybe you need to wait 6 months. Maybe we need to bump up that brokerage account, that will be able to sustain you while you take a sabbatical. I don’t love the higher earner leaving their job in this scenario, because they have the goal for financial independence. Do they have the goal for early retirement, or like before-65 retirement?

Madison Sharick: I didn’t have it written that they were dead set on early retirement at a specific age, but I think more importantly, they just want to make sure they’re on track for a normal retirement age. Anything earlier than that was kind of like the cream on top for them.

Mindy Jensen: I think that if the higher income earner leaves for a sabbatical, they want to take a year off, they want to take, you know, 3 years off, get the kids out of daycare and into school full-time. That’s a different scenario than “I want to quit.” And I think that if somebody is listening to this and they are in a similar position, hey, I think I want to quit, but I’m the higher earner, can I do it? Why do you want to ask yourself why you want to quit? What is your end goal? Do you just never want to work again? I think a lot of people don’t never want to work again, but some do. I mean, most people listening to this will get to the point where they don’t want to work anymore because they have to. But, you know, if you just want to take the 3 years off that your youngest is still in daycare and you decide, I don’t want to send them to daycare, I want to be home with them, or you decide, you know, I just need a break for 6 months, that’s a very different answer than “I want to quit, tell me if I can do that.” I can see people getting so stressed out or so overwhelmed with whatever’s going on at their job that they want to leave, and they’re not thinking about the long-term effects on what leaving would do to their financial independence number, their retirement number, their retirement date.

Madison Sharick: Personal finance is trade-offs. You know, you can’t do something without a trade-off. You’re always giving up something is what I’m saying. And what you might be giving up in this instance is if you need liquid funds, you might not be contributing to your 401(k) outside of the match, and you’re just stuffing in brokerage or savings account for a period of time. Scott, I know I’m probably making you sweat right now saying that, but you might have to give up a tax benefit in order to build the liquidity.

Scott Trench: I’ve been beating that drum for about 10 years here on this podcast. I believe that a part of the price of freedom is suboptimal tax efficiency. And further, I’ll even go further and say that if you don’t pay that price of suboptimal tax efficiency, in many cases, you must ride out the perfect FI journey, like the high-income journey where you max out all the retirement accounts, then you truly go to zero or stop working and then begin the Roth conversion ladder, and you actually isolate yourself out of some other options that are very common to households along the journey, including the entrepreneurial path that we talked about here, including, you know, things like self-employment or small business ownership or equity at your employer or sales, you know, or, you know, commission jobs, flexible work, those types of things. Because you must, your plan, if you go too far and you defer when you’re in very low income tax brackets in particular, you have a very high risk of negative tax bracket arbitrage. And then there’s a question that has to be modeled about whether that’s worth it, because in some cases it can be worth it to defer and then even pay the same or higher taxes later because of the way compounding works and how tax drag impacts returns, right? Like $100,000 invested and then taken out after 10% tax drag at the end is worth more than if you invested $90,000 right now and then took it out of the same tax bracket down the line. This is kind of complicated next-level math for those who can’t follow, but just trust me on that point that that’s how that works. You don’t want to pay taxes needlessly upfront. But if your tax bracket is much higher and your timeline is shorter, that benefit gets—it shrinks. And so there’s a good case that many people like Mindy, for example, specifically will negatively arbitrage their tax brackets because they deferred at relatively low income tax thresholds and now have to do Roth conversion ladders and those types of things at higher brackets, like 24%, than the money went in at. And that is true tax inefficiency that you got into in the name of efficiency early on in the journey. So I’m sorry, that probably confused everybody with that, but maybe Madison, were you able to follow what I was saying there?

Madison Sharick: I was, and I’m interested to—so you mentioned about Roth conversion ladders. So this is something I find the FI community talks about a lot and writes about a lot. In real life, not that many people do them.

Scott Trench: You got to actually follow through and stop working during that period, both you and your spouse, if you’re married. That story is very rare in the profile we just talked about, right? The household with kids. It’s probably less rare in single individuals or married couples without kids that are taking gap years for FI.

Evan Lawler: Would you agree with that?

Madison Sharick: Yeah. Yep.

Evan Lawler: I think that is a great tool.

Scott Trench: It should be in the arsenal.

Evan Lawler: It’s wonderful when you do very deep, very complex, intellectually stimulating, deep modeling. But yeah, it’s not there in the wild to the same degree that you’d think about based on how often it’s talked about.

Madison Sharick: Yeah. And I also find that with things like premium tax credits and trying to keep your income low, if both of you are truly early retired, being able to access something like those tax credits, oftentimes like sacrificing that is enough to not make people want to do Roth conversions, even if we do projections and it is favorable for them to do them. It’s hard to turn down what is perceived as free money through the tax credits.

Scott Trench: Are you setting me up to show off my tools here?

Madison Sharick: I think I might be. I’m interested to see what you’re gonna pull up. I liked the calculator that you pulled up before. I would use that with clients.

Scott Trench: Oh, thanks. Yes, that’s my budget software here.

Madison Sharick: Yeah, I love that.

Mindy Jensen: Scott, where can Madison find this budget calculator?

Scott Trench: You can find it at biggerpocketsmoney.com/budget. To your point, Madison, I think that the healthcare costs are the biggest unknown here. And so this, this tool here at biggerpocketsmoney.com/healthcarecosts, healthcare also redirects there. You’ll be able to see what your premium looks like, which, you know, scales based on age, which to your point, I think earlier is like the number one real risk factor here, right?

Evan Lawler: The fact that my health insurance premium at 35 might be $383 in Colorado and in my rating area, and $700 a month at age 55, is a big deal. And that’s what people are missing when they’re projecting their expenses, because that cost is going to ramp every year. You’re going to think it’s going to start at like $19,000 for a household like mine in Colorado, but it’s going to ramp every single year until my first kid rolls off. Then it’s going to come down a little bit, then it’s going to ramp again. My other kid’s going to come off, and then it’s going to keep climbing until I hit Medicare.

Madison Sharick: Oh, I love that this has a chart over time. That is so cool.

Evan Lawler: Yeah. So that tells you, like, oh, if you’re planning on a 4% rule, you also need a $250,000 buffer beyond the 4% rule. That’s the buffer beyond that to cover the increase over your starting healthcare costs, if you want to preserve the rest of your spending relative to inflation over that. And then the other part here, to your point, why are Roth conversions going to be so rare in the wild for households like this? Well, if I go over a cliff—everyone’s, a lot of people are familiar with this because it’s been beaten to death and it’s a really important point, so it should have been beaten to death—but if you go over the cliff for a household of 4, which is $128,600 in 2026, then you get no credit. Everyone’s familiar with that. But if you’re an actually good planner, you’re also going to know that your credit increases the more your MAGI decreases, even once you’re below that cliff, up to the full amount of the premium, which in this case is $14,965 here for this house over the year.

Scott Trench: Plus, I also put in an out-of-pocket estimate for healthcare costs. And then there’s no point in reducing your MAGI once you get 100% of the credit. But that is surely going to trump the tax benefit of Roth conversions in all but truly very wealthy situations here or, you know, wherever. So that is more important than Roth, is going to make them much rarer in the wild. But I do think that there is a use case for Roth conversions. If you go over the cliff, then you might as well go over the cliff and start thinking about the Roth conversion through to whichever tax bracket you’re comfortable with.

Madison Sharick: Yep, for sure.

Mindy Jensen: I’m curious why you don’t see people actually doing this Roth conversion, because you’re right, everybody talks about it. Everybody’s like, oh yeah, you just start the Roth conversion ladder, and that’s a 5-year ladder, and then it’s just in perpetuity, you have all this money. Well, in perpetuity if you do it every year, but then also you have to pay taxes on that Roth conversion. And that’s money that you can’t access for 5 years.

Scott Trench: I think there’s a lot of like theoretical optimization in the FI world. And I spent a lot of time attempting to pursue that theoretical optimization because I think it’s really important and has a use case. Like there are people who will actually pursue exactly what we talked about. They will achieve financial independence. They will begin withdrawing from tax-advantaged accounts in these sequences, sometimes using 72(t), sometimes using Roth conversions. They’ll have the intersection of those tools with the MAGI cliff and the subsidy scaling as your MAGI decreases in mind, and they’ll make better decisions and save themselves thousands of dollars a year and hundreds of thousands or millions over the course of a lifetime in tax benefit with good planning. It’s a real benefit. But also even more people will be like, no, I will not be managing my life to a 5-year Roth conversion cycle for liquidity access. And in practice, I just think we’re going to find it rarer still. We’re going to see more people do Roth conversions than who withdraw the principal from their Roth anytime before 59 and a half, and maybe even in their entire life.

Madison Sharick: Absolutely. When people do Roth conversions, usually it’s for the larger tax strategy and, you know, trying to smooth your taxable income over your lifetime, keeping a cap on RMDs in the future. Very rarely is it for the access to the principal after the 5-year window. You know, I’ve advised hundreds of clients at this point. I think I’ve had someone do that like twice, where they actually really needed the pocket of Roth principal. Usually when people are optimizers to this level, they’re just storing funds in brokerage. Like they’re high earners, they have some overflow, they’re putting it in a liquid place to use. In real life, I can tell you that is just so much easier than having to force yourself to do the Roth conversion. Like with the Roth conversion, you can be jeopardizing the premium tax credits. You also have to pay the tax too. And usually if you’re doing a Roth conversion, it’s better to pay the tax out of pocket and not from the conversion itself. So say goodbye to a chunk of money that’s in your savings account that you are paying to the IRS every time you do the conversion. People don’t like that part at all.

Mindy Jensen: Yeah, it’s not free. You have to pay taxes on that money at some point to convert from a 401(k) to a Roth IRA, or a traditional account to a Roth account. You have to pay the tax on that. When you convert to the Roth, you’re just getting by with not paying the 10% penalty for early withdrawal, because you’re not actually accessing those funds.

Scott Trench: What else should we talk about here, Madison, about this household before we adjourn?

Madison Sharick: We talked a lot about having funds in different buckets. And there’s one thing I will say for my Coast FIRE people. I consider myself a Coast FIRE person. I’ve kind of lived that. I advise people on it. Oftentimes I do have people who are pursuing Coast financial independence who are not interested in early retirement. I do have them just continuously stuff tax-advantaged accounts. So Scott, I think this is the counter to what you’ve been describing, of like getting liquidity by contributing to places that aren’t necessarily tax advantaged. For Coast FIRE people, I usually do have them stuff retirement accounts until the cows come home.

Scott Trench: Okay, fair enough. Yes, I think if you’re not going to use the accounts until retirement and you’re not planning on a big number, then my argument does not apply. I’d agree with that. Well, cool. Madison, where can people find out more about you?

Madison Sharick: So I’m a financial planner at hellonectarine.com. I’m one of about 2 dozen planners. Everyone’s fabulous. So check out Hello Nectarine. I’m also on Instagram @madimanagesmoney, and you spell Madi, M-A-D-I.

Scott Trench: Well, thank you very much for covering this with us. I think it’s a really important topic. I think it’s this in the grind, how do I access my wealth in some way, you know, problem that I think is hitting perhaps a majority of the FI community at this point. I think maybe a majority of people in the FI community as of 2026 are not FI, not just starting out, but in this kind of messy middle wondering how they can access some component of what they’ve built. And I think these are helpful tools. It’s not a clear, you’re in great shape. It’s, you got to keep your foot somewhat on the gas.

Evan Lawler: You got to leave some assets compounding here, but there are conditions in which you can seize the opportunities that are in front of you or be very flexible if you have access to liquidity and you have a pretty good handle on what you need to bridge and for how long. So thank you. It’s wonderful, wonderful stuff here. And we look forward to reconnecting in the future.

Mindy Jensen: Madi, thank you so much for your time today. And we’ll talk to you again soon.

Madison Sharick: That sounds good. Thanks guys.

Mindy Jensen: All right, Scott, that was Madison Sharick from Hello Nectarine, or Madi Manages Money on Instagram. She had a lot of really interesting things to say. What I found kind of surprising is that nobody does Roth conversions. She said it’s like 1 or 2% of her clients have done a Roth conversion. And, you know, that was really surprising to me, because everybody talks about it. Do you know anybody who’s done a Roth conversion, Scott?

Scott Trench: Well, this goes back to something controversial we talked about last year, right? When I was like, they’re the 4% rule people don’t exist. Like, that’s the core problem here. Is there’s this whole thing is, hey, you get to FI, you start withdrawing at 4%, and then that’s the promised land here. And we’ve observed for years that this is extraordinarily rare in the real world, and to the point where I had to mention it probably 10 times on the podcast before we met anybody, like a real human being who actually did that at an early age in the FI community. And now we’ve met a few, they do exist. I don’t know if they’ve stayed there, because it’s impossible to stay at the line of 4%. You don’t ratchet your spending.

Evan Lawler: It’s impossible to stay there forever. But there’s been people who have started there that we’ve met. But I think that’s the core problem is then, in order for you to do Roth conversions, you have to have that high deferred balance. You have to have the low income, you’ve got to manage your MAGI for the ACA subsidies, which chunks out a huge portion of the population. And then if you’re over the cliff or have other circumstances where that’s not important, then you’re going to be doing Roth conversions. And so yes, I think maybe this is the call out.

Scott Trench: Can we meet a real human being under the age of 50 who has done Roth conversions more than 3 years in a row?

Mindy Jensen: I would bump that up to age 55.

Scott Trench: Okay.

Mindy Jensen: But yeah, if you’ve done more than 3 years of Roth conversions in a row, or you know what, 3 years total, reach out to scott@biggerpocketsmoney.com or mindy@biggerpocketsmoney.com. We would love to hear your story. Even if you don’t want to be on the podcast, if you just want to share your story and we can say a listener said this.

Scott Trench: Maybe we’ll find more, because maybe there are certain circumstances that make a lot of sense to do Roth conversions. Like, for example, somebody in a type of business that creates a large taxable loss that they can use to offset ordinary income, that would be a great case for Roth conversions, right? But it wouldn’t fit into the bucket we’re looking for. We’re not really, that’s not really what we’re going for here. We’re going for someone who built up a large tax-deferred 401(k) balance and now Roth converts every year based on certain rules up to certain limits and is doing so consistently.

Evan Lawler: We’ll see. Let’s see. Let’s, if you, if that’s you, let us know. We would love to meet you. You’d be the first.

Mindy Jensen: Now we’re going to get inundated. You’re like, oh, okay, I guess it’s—

Evan Lawler: Yeah, maybe, maybe it’s really common. Maybe, maybe it’s just, maybe it’s our little boxes has kept us away from this cohort. But yeah, please email us, scott@biggerpocketsmoney.com, mindy@biggerpocketsmoney.com. We’d love to hear it.

Scott Trench: And we’d even more love to have you on the show and hear about the journey that got you to the point where you’re doing Roth conversions successfully in early retirement.

Mindy Jensen: And again, if you are withdrawing on the 4% rule, and you’re not generating any significant income, I do have a friend, Jolene, has a blog about wine, and she generates about $400 a year, but she is pulling from the 4% rule. I don’t think that counts, Scott. You think it counts? What’s $400 going to get you? That’s like a dollar a day.

Scott Trench: Someone’s Roth converting $400?

Mindy Jensen: No, no, she’s—this is different. This is the 4% rule. She is withdrawing per the 4% rule, but she also has a wine blog that generates about $400 a year.

Scott Trench: Yeah. Like, like that’s the thing, right? And then, then what counts? What doesn’t here? Now you’ve got self-employment income.

Mindy Jensen: A dollar a day. I’m saying that that doesn’t count.

Scott Trench: I think that’s fair. I think that doesn’t count.

Mindy Jensen: So therefore Darren and Jolene actually do withdraw per the 4% rule. But yeah, if you withdraw per the 4% rule and you don’t have any other income or any significant income, we would love to hear from you too. All right, Scott, we should get out of here. But before we do, great big thanks to Nectarine. If you are looking to connect with Nectarine, biggerpocketsmoney.com/nectarine. We’ll get you right to them so you can set up an appointment with Madison or any of the other financial planners or financial advisors that they have on their site. And as always, you can find all of the awesome show partners at biggerpocketsmoney.com/fipro. That’s biggerpocketsmoney.com/fipro. All right, that wraps up this episode of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast. He is Scott Trench. I am Mindy Jensen saying take a hike, motorbike.

Brand New! (June 2026) BiggerPockets Money App

Close Welcome Bar