BiggerPockets Money Podcast

He Bought Real Estate at the Peak. Now He’s Paying the Price

BiggerPockets Money Podcast
BiggerPockets Money Podcast
He Bought Real Estate at the Peak. Now He’s Paying the Price
Loading
/

Show Notes

Can you build wealth through real estate without being the one managing the properties? Paul Shannon has operated roughly 500 units and invested passively in more than 40 real estate deals, giving him plenty of experience on both sides of the business. He joins Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench to discuss the tradeoffs between active and passive investing, what he’s learned from deals that went wrong, and how he evaluates sponsors and investment opportunities.

They also dig into rising interest rates, real estate debt funds, diversification, and why Paul thinks today’s market could offer opportunities for investors who know what they’re doing. If you’re considering passive real estate investing or wondering how to incorporate real estate into your financial independence plan, this episode offers a candid look at both the potential rewards and the risks.

To go beyond the podcast:

Connect with Paul Shannon:

We believe financial independence is attainable for anyone no matter when or where you’re starting. Let’s get your financial house in order!

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript

Read Full Transcript

📄 Full Episode Transcript

Mindy Jensen: What can you learn from investing in 45 real estate deals that makes you a better real estate operator? As an operator, Paul has raised $10 million and owns roughly 500 units. He has also invested passively in more than 40 deals. Today, he’s sharing what he’s learned from both sides of the table and how to decide which real estate investment strategy is right for you. Hello, hello, hello, and welcome to the BiggerPockets Money Podcast. My name is Mindy Jensen. And with me as always is my co-host, Scott Trench.

Scott Trench: Thanks, Mindy. Great to be here. That’s a wonderful intro. I’m gonna take it to the house. Paul, thank you so much for coming on the BiggerPockets Money Podcast today to talk about your money story. We are super excited to have you.

Paul Shannon: Scott, Mindy, I’m excited to be here. Thank you.

Scott Trench: So let’s start from the beginning. Where does your money story begin?

Paul Shannon: Trying to make some, that’s really where it began. And I was in sales. I graduated all the way back in 2003. And like a lot of people that come out of college, I wasn’t quite sure what I wanted to do with my life. I had a business major. So I went into sales. It was fun. It was rewarding in some ways, but I was not in control of my time. I could see that in many cases, I didn’t necessarily want my manager’s job. And I kind of struggled for a while in figuring out what my path would be. I found the FIRE movement and I thought that that was really sensible. It was like, hey, what’s the worst that could happen here? I save a lot more money than I need to, and I give myself a lot more optionality. Let’s try this, right? So I started saving a big majority of my paycheck, about 50% of what I would take home. You know, and my idea was that I could hopefully retire by 40. I was reading a lot of The Mad Fientist, Mr. Money Mustache, and a lot of the popular people that made FIRE mainstream. I understood the Trinity Study, the 4% rule, and I planned to eventually, once I reached my number, live off my principal and essentially take 3% instead of 4%, be a little bit more conservative and take 3% of the money that I had saved and live off of that on an inflation-adjusted basis. So I was fairly successful in achieving my goals and saving the money that I wanted to save. But as I got closer to the finish line, I started to get a little worried about mainly sequence of returns risk, and that, you know, hey, if I retire when I’m 40 and at 42 there’s a big drawdown in the market, a bear market, and it really erodes my principal balance and I still have to live off of that principal. That’s where, you know, FIRE sometimes falls apart, where you end up drawing down a lot of that principal and it doesn’t come back, and you end up having to go back to work. So I didn’t want that to happen. And I was looking for other ways to create side income and basically supplement that nest egg with actual income on the side. And I saw real estate as really the path to being able to achieve that. So that was probably back in 2010. I watched a lot of HGTV and house flipping shows and got really excited about that stuff, but never acted. I was very slow to progress and actually take action, right? And I should have started probably a lot sooner at that time. If I was buying in 2010, we were at market lows right after the Great Financial Crisis. I would’ve done very, very well. But it took me until 2016 to buy my first duplex. And from there I started scaling, bought houses to flip. I employed the BRRRR method. I worked my way into small multifamily, 2 and 4 units, then got into an 8-unit, then went to a 40-unit property, and eventually started syndicating deals, collecting other people’s money, pulling it together, and buying assets that were larger than I can afford on my own. So I’m kind of a hybrid investor now, but I do real estate investing full-time. I’m less worried about retiring because I really do enjoy what I do and have a lot of flexibility. I could see doing it well off into the future. But that’s kind of my story in a nutshell.

Mindy Jensen: Had you reached financial independence or reached the number that you were aiming for before you started doing the real estate investing?

Paul Shannon: No, I had made good progress. I would say I was probably, let’s say, 65 to 70% of where I wanted to be. And I was at a point in my career where I was just about to have my third child, my son, and I was traveling. I was in medical device capital equipment sales. I was a consultant, so I had a region that was quite large and was overnight about 80 nights a year. I was doing a lot of traveling. My health wasn’t where I wanted it to be, sitting behind the wheel of a car all the time. My back was hurting a lot, and I just, I felt like my life was kind of not going the way I wanted it. It was sort of like one event after another that sort of forced me into making a decision, like, hey, what’s the worst that could happen at this point? I’ve got a nest egg I can fall back on. I’ve got a career with a good track record and a good reputation that I could come back to. The biggest risk at this point is not taking a chance on myself. And I had invested in real estate. I had bought 3 single-family homes and a duplex up until that point. I saw the scalability, and really the only thing that was holding me back was time. I didn’t have time because I was out of town so much. I was working so many hours to really dedicate to being a full-time real estate investor. But that was my plan at the time, was to go into real estate full-time. I was going to give myself 2 years. I certainly hadn’t replaced the income that I was leaving behind with 3 homes and a duplex, but I thought that if I had dedicated myself full-time, like I did to my career, to real estate investing, I could really make some waves. I was lucky to get some tailwinds, but it was around 2019 that I left my W-2 and invested full-time and started to scale.

Mindy Jensen: So between 2016 and 2019, how did you set up your finances so that you had some money to live off of while you were scaling up your real estate? Because I think that holds a lot of people back. Ooh, I want to start investing in real estate, maybe I want to do it full-time, but I don’t have enough money and I don’t have enough time to just jump into real estate investing.

Paul Shannon: Well, I would be remiss to not mention that my wife works as well. So she had a W-2 job, and that was our safety net. That was our health insurance. And that was going to be, you know, a little skinny to live off of. But we also, through saving a lot of money and listening to the FIRE movement, I was very motivated to pay off our primary residence, our home. So we did that, and I did that before I left my job. And I immediately, after I paid it off, took out a HELOC. So I took out a home equity line of credit to have, almost as an insurance policy, but also as a source of capital to buy real estate with on a short-term basis. So as I mentioned, I was flipping houses. I was using the BRRRR method. So I would buy houses in cash with the money from the home equity line of credit. I would fix ’em up, I would fill ’em with a renter, and then I would refinance them through traditional bank debt, rinse and repeat over and over and over again. Or I’d flip houses, I’d sell it, and then whatever profit I would generate, that would go into my business account where I could then use that for liquidity to buy and purchase homes. So through that process, we had kind of a good thing going for a few years. And like I said, we got some tailwinds too, right? 2019, 2020, going into COVID, money got very, very cheap, rents went up quite a bit, asset values increased quite a bit, and we were part of that. So we had bought, I think, 19 single-family homes in 2019.

Scott Trench: What market?

Paul Shannon: This is all in Indiana. So I live in Indianapolis. So it was in Indianapolis as well as Evansville, Indiana, which is about 3 hours south of me, which is one of our primary markets today as well. That was really my strategy, was like, hey, let’s reduce our outgoing bills, our liabilities, that being in the form of a house payment. We didn’t have that anymore. So we had a lot of extra cash to cover our expenses, a lot of which were discretionary expenses that we could always cut back on if times got tough. Thankfully, with those tailwinds that we caught, we didn’t have to deal with that, but that was the plan and it worked out.

Scott Trench: This was a great time to invest in real estate. At some point you transitioned to investing in syndications or, you know, private equity-funded real estate. When did that transition happen and what was that timeline like?

Paul Shannon: Well, I had been investing as an LP, a limited partner, where I would take my funds and invest with another operator in a different market or a different asset class. Also starting in 2016, I saw it as a way, I was very interested in commercial real estate, one, but I also saw it as a way to diversify away from myself as an operator or real estate investor, away from my market. The Midwest has some great attributes to it as far as investing. It’s cash flow, it’s steady, doesn’t have the big swings, the ups and downs that you might see from a Vegas or a Phoenix, but it also doesn’t have the big appreciation you might have in the Sunbelt, let’s say. So I was getting geographic diversification. I was getting asset class diversification: self-storage, retail, mobile home parks, debt funds. These are, you know, core asset classes within real estate, commercial real estate, but I didn’t have a core competency in those different asset classes. So it was essential for me to find the right operators to invest in that I could trust. That diversification strategy started back in 2016. And then when I started having success in single-family and got into multifamily, I kind of took what I had learned as an LP and what looked good from what I could see in my chair from the GPs that I invested with, and took my operation strategy in my market and then started to look to partner with other limited partners where I was the general partner and I was the one operating and running the asset. So that all started back in about 2021, and then we scaled into a market that became very difficult starting in 2022. So, you know, interest rates rose quite a bit, we got a lot of headwinds.

Scott Trench: You bought real estate, rental real estate, in a great time period and scaled that up and did very well, like a lot of BiggerPockets members. And then you turned to syndications at, I would imagine, the absolute worst possible moment to do so, in 2021, right before interest rates went up, right at peak pricing. I presume you bought through mid-2022, you entered in 2021, you bought through mid-2022, and then transactions stopped and you’re stuck. I don’t even know if holding the bag is the right terminology for this pattern here, but it just paused. It’s all locked in. There’s no transaction volume. You can’t really value the assets. And the stuff that I got into in 2021, I’ve just written to zero. I got an email the other day from one of the deals I’m in about how absurdly below the debt value the asset is at this point, that it’s gone. It’s gone. How did that work out for you? I know you were able to avoid, across your portfolio, the total catastrophe that would’ve been an extrapolation of my 2 syndicated bets, but how did that go for you?

Paul Shannon: I certainly have taken some losses and received a similar email about 2 weeks ago on an LP position that I took back in early 2022. Still trying to make sense of that, and those sting for sure. On the whole, I’ve done about 45 deals as an LP and 4 of them have gone south. 2 of them are total equity wipeouts, 100% loss. So those, you know, that hurts, and that speaks to diversification.

Scott Trench: Do you consider those losses the ones that are closed out, deal’s gone, it’s over? Or do you have others? Like, for example, my deal is technically still alive. It’s been dead for 3 years, but it’s also still an operating entity. It has not folded yet. And I’m sure some people have not marked it to zero like I did 3 years ago. Define what 4 failures looks like out of 45.

Paul Shannon: Well, 2 were fraud, so 2 were bad actors, and some friends were involved in that deal as well. Those deals ended up being litigated against the sponsor, both of which are either in jail or going to jail. Those are tough, right? Because you don’t see that coming necessarily, especially when you get somebody that vouches for that sponsor.

Scott Trench: One of those was not a real estate deal, right?

Paul Shannon: It was an ATM deal. Yeah, you probably know of that one. One was a Texas multifamily deal. The other one was the ATM deal. And then 2 others are similar to what your story is, where they’re still in limbo right now, but I’ve marked them down to zero and I’m fairly confident that’s where they’re headed, just based on communication and knowing what the assets were purchased for, what they’re worth today, et cetera. Those are tough, but from an active real estate investing standpoint, I had a couple of big wins back in 2021 that I then exited 2023, 2024, which provided a fair bit of liquidity. And we started to build a solid investor base and track record based on not being the hype guys, not being the people that were out there trying to sell the promise of riches or financial freedom or easy income or passive income. We were the people saying, hey, watch out. You know, in 2022, we talked a lot about it on LinkedIn and other podcasts. Look, interest rates were at, you know, you could finance multifamily real estate for around 3%. Same with a single-family home, right? Right around that rate. Federal funds rate was zero. Inflation at that time was about 9%. Prior to that, you had Jerome Powell talking about inflation being transitory. It’s kind of going to take care of itself, right? And go away on its own. Well, it didn’t do that. And he started to change his tone and telegraph that rates were going to rise, that inflation was more structural. We’re still dealing with inflation today, right? Just got a hot inflation report as we’re recording this this morning. And at that point, it looked to me like, hey, you know, if you study financial history and you understand that inflation typically leads to a higher federal funds rate, higher short-term financing rates, and rates go up, you know, floating rate debt, that debt burden becomes more burdensome and that puts downward pressure on cash flows. And at the time, everybody was buying multifamily real estate or commercial real estate with floating rate debt. That was the only way to get it done because you could get more proceeds, you could get higher leverage. But that cuts both ways. When interest rates rise, that really can burn a sponsor. And we stayed away from that. We did not take out any floating rate debt. It was all fixed rate, and we didn’t have to deal with that variable cost rising, which is what put a lot of sponsors in trouble. So that’s how we survived. But while we weren’t buying multifamily real estate, we underwrote, I think, 200 deals in 2022, give or take, maybe 10 in either direction. And we put offers in on 60 properties and we got absolutely zero of them. We were about 15 to 20% off of broker guidance on every single deal we underwrote because we were underwriting to fixed-rate debt, and because we could not get as much proceeds, we couldn’t underwrite to as high returns. And we also weren’t thinking that rent growth, which in 2022 was 5, 10% in certain markets, was going to go out into the future forever, where some people were underwriting to that. In hindsight, you know, it was very frustrating to not win these deals, but we’re glad we didn’t buy them because a lot of them are underwater or in trouble or going back to banks, et cetera, et cetera. We pivoted and we started raising money for debt funds because that’s what I was investing in personally in my LP portfolio. And we had all these investors that thought what we were saying made some sense. We started accruing capital and we started investing in debt funds that had high minimum investments or had access barriers that traditional investors just couldn’t get into, high minimum investments, et cetera.

Mindy Jensen: Can you explain what that is? I’ve heard this phrase debt fund, and I’m not sure that everybody is familiar with what that actually means.

Paul Shannon: You know, a lot of times in the single-family home space, if you’re an investor, you might borrow private money, right, from a wealthy individual, a doctor, a lawyer, whoever it might be. And it comes at a little bit of a higher interest rate than you might get from a bank. But there might not be as much red tape or qualifications. They may not be so concerned about your credit score. They just want to know that they’re going to get their interest payment. And at the end, when the balloon is due, you’re going to pay it off and either refinance it or have sold that house. Basically, a debt fund is a collection of those types of loans. So a debt fund will loan to a large group of investors that do that. So you’re getting a diversified portfolio of loans. It could be single-family homes, it could be commercial real estate. It really could be anything. Business debt is fairly popular today and somewhat toxic, in my opinion, but there are a lot of loans out there that are originated outside of the traditional banking sector, outside of the government, that are done by private individuals. And debt funds are just a pool of those loans that are aggregated together and run by an operator who specializes in, or hopefully specializes in, originating these loans.

Mindy Jensen: Do I get to choose what kinds of debt I am investing in? Because I don’t want to invest in business loans at all. I don’t want to invest in multifamily at all. I don’t mind the short-term investments in the smaller individual properties. If I am investing in a debt fund, do I get to choose, or is it just, here’s money, do what you want with it?

Paul Shannon: Typically the sponsor of the debt fund will have a strategy and a thesis and then a subsequent buy box. And your job as an investor, if you’re interested in investing in, say, a debt fund portfolio of single-family loans, would be to find an operator who’s just specifically focused on that. So yes, and their operating agreement and PPM, their private placement memorandum, should spell out the guidelines and guardrails of what they can and can’t invest in. So in that case, you would want to find somebody that’s specific to your interests and your asset-class-specific thesis.

Scott Trench: Paul, how all in are you on this? Like, this is clearly your business and all that, but do you have stocks? Do you have other rentals that you privately manage as well? Like, how would I think about the pie chart of Paul’s net worth across various asset classes, lumping all of this syndication stuff across — I get it, different commercial types of real estate, fund debt, equity, all that kind of stuff. How would you give us the shape of your position?

Paul Shannon: I’m about 35% of my overall net worth is in stocks. Ten to 15% is in fixed income, bonds, or precious metals — gold, silver, miners. And then about 50% is in real estate, divided between limited partner positions where I don’t play an active role and I’ve decided to invest with another sponsor, and at that point I’m kind of hands-off. I’d say about 20% is in that camp. And then 30% is active investments, where I have signed on either recourse or non-recourse loans and have direct ownership in the property, either in a joint venture, or it’s just my wife and I, or it’s a syndication where I’ve brought in limited partners who have made up a big chunk of the equity we needed to get the deal done. So, 30% active real estate, 20% passive real estate, 35% stocks, 15% other is about where I’m at today.

Scott Trench: So we’re not all in on this, but that portion that is real estate — and that is the passive investments, the passive-active hybrid syndicated world — surely in aggregate that has underperformed a passive index fund over the last five years, right? The question is, what will happen over the next five years? Because you think all these things even out eventually across these different asset classes. The index funders will all argue that because they’re low fees and on average you can’t really beat ’em over long periods of time. But you know that the swings will happen at various points where one asset class races ahead of the next and then it depresses for— how do you think about that in terms of your position? Do you agree with that framing?

Paul Shannon: Sure, yeah. I mean, I think that the market is constantly operating as a pendulum, swinging from fear to euphoria, and it really never stops in the middle. So you’ve got to kind of figure out where it is and position accordingly. In 2022, the market in real estate was at a peak, and there was a lot of hype, right? Cap rates were compressed. There were coaching classes all over the place. That’s your first signal that something has gone awry here. Everybody’s getting into real estate, including the neighbors you talk to and the people at the gas station. Real estate is just so popular — well, that’s the time to be a little bit more cautious. Whereas today the euphoria is gone. There’s a lot more fear out there. The bases have been reset. There’s been a 30%, 35% decline in a lot of markets. There’s less lending activity going on, there’s less listings, there’s not really any coaching classes happening anymore. So, to me, when everybody’s running in the opposite direction because they’re scared — take a quote out of Warren Buffett’s book, be greedy when everyone else is fearful and fearful when everyone else is greedy. And today, I think — I don’t think everybody’s necessarily so fearful, that sentiment is so low that it’s time to just load up the truck, so to speak, in real estate. But I do think today is a better time to buy than 2022, if you can get deals at a decent basis that cash flow day one and you’ve got multiple exit options and a longer-term horizon. And I think that answers your question. How am I looking at it? Real estate is cyclical, just like every other asset class, but time heals a lot of wounds. So if you can just hang on — some of the dogs in your portfolio, if you’ve got debt that’s not maturing until 2033, that’s six, seven years from now, we’ve got a fair bit of time to see what happens. And in that time, if you are an owner of this real estate, your job is to really operate it as efficiently as possible. Keep expenses low, keep occupancy high, try to increase rents as you can, whatever the market allows, and stay on top of deferred maintenance. And if you can do those things, probably in six or seven years you’re going to come out okay. And let’s hope interest rates go down too, but hope is not an investing strategy. So we have to do what we can do and control what we control. So I look at it like that, and there’s certainly some deals in our portfolio that we’re unsure of where they’re going to end up. I don’t think we have any that are going to be in a position where we can’t refinance or hold on a little bit longer. And I think that’s the problem with a lot of syndicators — they went in with a three-year business plan, and they needed everything to go right. They had one plan, Plan A, and if that didn’t work out, everything fell apart. And with leverage, it falls apart really fast. If you can kind of mitigate some of those issues and create Plan A, B, and C and have a longer-term horizon for your investments, you’re going to be okay. That’s how I look at it.

Scott Trench: Yeah, I also think that, you know, another strategy you can deploy here is you can just take the assets that you bought a few years ago, mark them up, raise new capital from a new crop of LPs, transfer them into the new fund, pay yourself out the fee for the success of the fund, and stick a religious affinity marketing call to action on page two to hide your bad strategy on page three, right? That’s a possible outcome for syndicators. Is this in there?

Mindy Jensen: Scott, I’m not an expert, but that sounds a little fraudulent.

Scott Trench: I don’t know. I think that is literally happening across many funds right now. I don’t know if it’s fraud to tell people exactly what you’re doing in the PPM and then do exactly that. I just think you have really terrible, uninformed LPs who have no idea what’s going on.

Mindy Jensen: Well, taking advantage of somebody who doesn’t know what they’re doing — is that fraud? Maybe that’s just being a jerk.

Paul Shannon: I think you nailed it right there, Mindy, and that is going on in the market. I actually know somebody that is doing that very thing you just discussed, Scott. This year I launched a book called Both Sides of the Table — my experience as a fund manager, general partner, and limited partner, my experience coming up in this space. I talk about my experiences with fraud. I talk about some of the tactics that the gurus use, like you just talked about, Scott, and spell out that, hey, this is not for the faint of heart. If you’re going to get into this, this could help you on your FIRE journey because it can create passive income. It’s not passive on the front end, as you’re evaluating these deals and understanding the space and learning who the right sponsors are to invest in. But once you allocate your capital, it can provide income and diversification and lead you down the path of FIRE. But there are a whole bunch of potholes and landmines you can step in along the way. And my book is really kind of a guide to putting not just the principles of passive investing out there, but kind of the practice of it. How do you successfully deploy capital over a long period of time, diversify, and come out successful on the other end as a passive investor? And it’s avoiding some of the bad actors that maybe are doing things that aren’t necessarily illegal, but are doing things that are in their best interests that are not aligned with their LPs, Mindy. And I think there’s a ton of that. LPs have gotten a lot wiser because they’ve had to, as they’ve gotten burned over the last couple years. And I think some of that stuff’s going away, thankfully.

Mindy Jensen: Yes, thankfully some of that is going away, but it’s not all going away. This unique strategy that Scott just described and you confirmed is actually out there — a GP is the guy running it, the LP is the person contributing money to it, investing in it. For those of you who are unaware, what do LPs need to be looking out for as the GPs get more — let’s be generous and call it creative — with their offerings? Because I lost money in syndications before it was cool, and that kind of burned me way back in like 2019. So I am not currently losing money in any of these syndications like Scott is, but I want to prevent people from losing money. I mean, I have seen some really great pitch decks that are actually garbage if you look behind them, but if you don’t know to look behind it, you’re like, wow, this is really awesome.

Scott Trench: Paul, I want to challenge a part of Mindy’s premise here, because I agree that there are some pretty flashy pitch decks, but I have yet to come across a pitch deck that says, here’s what we’re buying, here’s the price, here are the comps that we’ve pulled, here’s the cap rate, here’s the interest rate, here’s our assumption for rent, here’s our assumption for exit cap rates, and then it’s truly trash. Where I see the true trash is I get Jesus on page two, pretty pictures of the properties throughout the deck, and no actual economic numbers deep in the detail stack. So it seems like the truly trash deals tend to be fluff across the deck instead of an actual investment thesis. But you have more experience — you know, whatever my n is, you have ten times as much exposure to this space as I do.

Mindy Jensen: I will rebut that, Scott, and say comps can be cherry-picked. As a buyer’s agent, I don’t cherry-pick comps — I show them all. But as a seller’s agent, when the appraiser’s coming over, you bet I cherry-pick the comps to make it look like my property is priced as high as it possibly can be compared to all the properties that have sold recently, so that my appraisal comes in as high as possible. There’s some lazy appraisers out there who will just take my word for it and be like, oh wow, you pulled all my comps for me, thanks so much. They go off of what I comped, and all of a sudden my property appraises — shockingly — for the exact amount of the contract. But I think that there are people who will cherry-pick a lot of this data.

Scott Trench: I am not saying that a thoughtful investment approach that has all these comps can’t be dead wrong and lose you all your money — that’s not what I’m saying. I’m just saying that I like to believe that the pitch deck I saw and lost my money in was a thesis that was grounded in a set of assumptions that were, in hindsight, comically wrong, rather than affinity marketing and pretty pictures where you just throw and die, hoping the market carries you on a deal — which I see from time to time. That’s my distinction here. Not that you put together a concrete, real model and proposal that has been dead wrong.

Paul Shannon: These syndicators, they want to sell you using consumer marketing tactics — urgency language, shiny pitch decks, fancy webinars. It works, right? It works in consumer marketing, it works in the syndication space. I always challenge people that are looking to become limited partners, or have a few deals under their belts, to think more like capital allocators. The default answer from a capital allocator is always no, and they really don’t care about a shiny pitch deck — they care about the details. And I would say that anyone who’s interested in this space, if you hear that this is less risky than stock market investing, or someone tries to compare this to the stock market and why it’s so much better because the stock market is a casino, they’re either trying to sell you something or they’ve never lost money. Any of those tactics are watchouts. I would not let FOMO, the fear of missing out, take over your investment analysis thesis. And I think, really, you can’t be great at this unless you start to develop pattern recognition. So as a newer LP, I challenge myself to get onto distribution lists of as many syndicators from as many different asset classes, from as many different markets as possible, and look at their deals and try to start to underwrite them and reverse-engineer how they put together their pitch decks. And I can tell you, after doing that a couple dozen times, you start to see some of these patterns stick out. And then when you see a good deal that meets your risk tolerance, which I think is extremely important to identify, you know it, and you jump on it. So it’s just practice. Passive investing is not 100% passive, certainly not at first. You need a deal funnel, you need a network. Ideally, you join a group like PassivePockets, part of the BiggerPockets network, where you can share ideas, share experiences with other investors who maybe have been there before and done this, or have invested with someone that you are thinking of investing in. I can tell you that I’ve saved some money by reaching out to other investors, saying, hey, have you ever heard of XYZ Group? Oh yeah, don’t invest with those guys, they’re terrible, this is what happened, they don’t communicate, they lost my money, or whatever. But just those little tidbits can kind of give you some additional reinforcement that, yes, I’m making a good decision, or no, this is not something I should invest in. And I would say, we talked about it a little bit before, it is so critical to diversify. You can bet on yourself, you can put all your eggs in one basket if it’s, you know, the right moment in time, and there are certainly people that have done that and made a ton of wealth. But if you’re investing with other people, or you’re investing in stocks, or you’re investing with sponsors of syndications, I believe you need to divide your bets. In the case of the fraud deals that I was involved in, if I had gone all in on those, that could have been a catastrophe for my entire plan and future. So having, you know, kind of a plan in place and looking at, hey, where do I want to be in ten years? I think this is like what a lot of people in the FIRE community think about, right? It’s like, hey, I’m 35, I want to retire when I’m 45 — how do I get there? What do I want my life to be like when I’m 45? How much income am I going to need? You kind of work backwards from there and think about how you can set up your days. We start with probably your years, then your weeks, then your days. How can you set those up and stack ’em so you can get to your goal eventually? It’s the same with passive real estate investing. How much do I want to have invested in self-storage? How much do I want to have invested in multifamily? What are even the attributes of those asset classes, and what makes them different? What role do they play in my portfolio? Those are things you have to understand. So you really have to be interested in this, and this style of investing is not for everybody. I will say that you have to kind of stay on top of it. You don’t necessarily have to deal with the tenants, termites, and toilets of being an active landlord, but you do have to understand how deals are structured, who you’re investing in, where the risks lie, and where your exposure is.

Scott Trench: You say I got stocks at 35, I got other at 15, I’ve got truly passive, LP-only positions at 20, and I’ve got this active hodgepodge at 30. How do you think about spending relative to your portfolio in the context of this hodgepodge? I imagine relatively low income that is being produced from the portfolio. I imagine very lumpy income. I imagine what amounts to kind of lottery-ticket-esque potential outcomes in the active position, where carried interest could produce a huge outcome or could produce very relatively little. How does one plan a life and live a Tuesday on a portfolio like this, relative to like a traditional 3% or 4% withdrawal sequence?

Paul Shannon: I would say paramount is to have reserves in tow. So I’ve got a high-yield savings account to keep liquid cash available if we ever need it, because, to your point, there is lumpy income — sometimes a windfall, other times it’s dry for quite a while. And the income is okay. Some of our earlier positions that we still hold today produce really good income with fixed-rate debt, and some of the stuff we’ve taken on that hasn’t seen the rent growth is a lot less. That’s hard to answer, Scott, because it used to be like, all right, here’s — I know what I spend, I track it, I put it into Empower, which used to be Personal Capital, and I can see exactly what my spending habits are, where everything is going. I kind of came up with, okay, this is what I’ve spent over the last five years, this is what I’m going to spend plus inflation over the next five years, and here’s how much I’m making. Today it’s a lot less like that, which is probably not what you want to hear, but it’s less organized. We have income coming in, so it’s not like the spigot has been shut off entirely and we have to start thinking about drawing down principal. It’s more like, when the income is there, we might spend it, we might save it, but if it ever were a point where we had to dip into reserves or principal, the spending gets cut big time. So I guess that’s the mindset, and it’s a little less, I guess, technical than theoretical.

Mindy Jensen: What does your personal reserve fund look like in terms of monthly spending? Do you keep on hand twelve months because your income isn’t so predictable, or do you keep more or less?

Paul Shannon: It’s probably more like six months — six months in high-yield savings. And we still have credit lines. I’ve got my home equity line of credit, which is untapped. And then we have a business line of credit as well on some lower-leverage commercial real estate that’s in our portfolio personally. So I look at that as cash reserves, in a way, if we needed to dip into that. And I also have whole life cash value life insurance that we could use too, if we ever needed to tap it. So we haven’t needed to tap credit lines or life insurance at this point for our living needs, but that high-yield savings account does come in handy sometimes for short term.

Mindy Jensen: I like having different buckets to pull from. In terms of monthly or annual spending, how much of that does your wife’s income cover?

Paul Shannon: Probably like 75%, maybe.

Mindy Jensen: Okay, so the bulk of your expenses are covered — and these are your freewheeling expenses, these aren’t your super-tight core expenses. If you had to cut out everything discretionary, she would cover 75% of that?

Paul Shannon: Correct.

Mindy Jensen: Okay.

Paul Shannon: Income that I make is either going to saving or reinvesting into additional investments, or it’s fun money. Her income is more aligned with just our needs, and my income is more aligned with our wants.

Mindy Jensen: I want to share this with anybody who might only have the HELOC. In 2006, my HELOC was closed by my bank. Thank you, Chase, for closing the HELOC for absolutely no reason whatsoever. At that point in time, my income hadn’t dropped, my house value hadn’t dropped. And they said, oh, we’re just not going to let you have this anymore. And then 2007, 2008, and my husband worked for the government, we didn’t have any issues, but it was very shocking that they would close the HELOC for, it seemed like, no reason. So I just want to let everybody know that your HELOC is not a guarantee. The money that you have pulled out, even if they close it, you still have the ability to pay that back on a schedule, but they might close it at any time with no warning. And you’re just out of luck. So I wanted to make sure to plant that little seed in somebody’s head. I think 1,000 episodes ago, somebody on the show had said, oh, they will never close my HELOC. They could. It’s their choice to close it.

Paul Shannon: 100%.

Scott Trench: What I was hearing is this is a kind of hard time for you guys, it sounds like, right? This is not like sunshine and roses situation. And the root cause of the situation is the correlation. It’s not this particular market cycle, it’s the fact that your portfolio is so highly correlated in one direction, right? We have real estate, we have 20% passive and 30%. And yes, there are different asset classes, different geographies, so there’s some diversification within that, but this is a highly sensitive to interest rate situation. And a large percentage of that has been, is likely weighted by multifamily specifically, which has had a really challenging environment. And so that’s the problem. That all begins to work against you at once, and you’re conservative enough where things are fine, but we’re not eating at Eddie V’s anymore. We’re eating at Ruby Tuesday. It’s still, you still go out to dinner, but that’s a challenge there. And this is a cyclical thing related to the asset classes you’ve chosen. There may come a day in the next 5 to 10 years when things are going very well, and you own the building that Eddie V is in, and Ruby Tuesday is a long distant memory. That’s not where you’re at right now. And that could flip for other people who are 40% invested in AI, for example, right? That’s got to go well. And if it doesn’t, then there’s going to be a similar type of correlation experience that could happen to many people who think that they are diversified across global equities when really they’re concentrated in one giant mega-tech blob. The lesson here for a lot of these things is there’s a concentration bet to get rich, and then there’s a diversification play to stay rich and stabilize that spend over the time period. And I don’t know exactly how to do that. I think that’s going to be debated for a long time here. But how am I doing? Do you think that this is a fair commentary on your situation, Paul?

Paul Shannon: Yeah, all in all, from a business perspective, we’re fine. Personally, we are financially in a good position. But we are not accelerating our net worth like we once were. And that has to do with the cyclicality of real estate. It is a very difficult time to acquire. Thankfully, as we’ve talked about before, we avoided a lot of the issues in some of the acquisitions we could have made that would’ve made our lives a lot more difficult than they are today. So I’m thankful for that. But to acquire today, we talked about sentiment being a little bit down and the pendulum has swung more towards fear than euphoria. Meaning that I think today, if you buy, of course, using the right fundamentals and acquiring at the right basis and understanding your market and being competent enough to operate in that market, et cetera, I think in 5 to 10 years, you’re going to be really, really happy that you did. I think it’s a good time to buy.

Scott Trench: So let’s talk about that, because I was at the PassivePockets conference and I was on a panel. It was like 4 super white dudes with all of the same exact glasses on the panel, all in just like slightly different shades of gray with our hair. That was the only distinguishable difference in there. But I remember being up there, the one other difference that there was in the group was I was the only person who was like, isn’t it kind of go time here in the syndication investment world? Like, this is the blood in the streets thing, right? We got famous dudes getting indicted for fraud. We got famous dudes losing their properties back to the bank. We got foreclosures happening. We’ve got the lowest transaction volume in years in the space. Surely, surely somebody should be bullish. That was not the sentiment. There was just overwhelming caution still in there. Maybe I’m wrong on that, but to me, I don’t know what else you get from a buy signal in this space. Like, it seems like every single flag that you can check for this is a buyer’s market in this type of commercial real estate space is green at this point. Not every deal, but just in general that this is the time to deploy capital in there. And yet, a lot of guys are not really doing that, that the capital was deployed a while back and the reverse is not happening. They’re not putting their capital in at this moment in time. I did this last year. You can argue I was early. I probably was by a year, but I made a big play in real estate last year because of this analysis. Maybe that’s the worry people have with it, but I’m comfortable with that decision and believe I’ll be rewarded over a 10-year period. Why don’t you think more people are doing that?

Paul Shannon: Because of human nature, right? People are fearful when everybody else is fearful and greedy when everybody else is greedy, when it should be the other way around. If everybody’s greedy, you should look the other way and say, hmm, why is there so much hype right now? If everybody’s fearful, you should think, well, asset values are really depressed. Everything’s on sale. In 10 years, I’m going to be great for doing this if I buy today. Very few people have the fortitude to, I think, take that approach. But I agree with you, and I think now is an attractive time to buy. I think it’s hard to buy because interest rates are very elevated. Whatever is on the market is usually listed just to see what the seller can get. They’re not forced to sell. They don’t need to sell. It’s not a very good time to sell, so not many are bringing properties to market. But where there’s going to be opportunity are forced sellers. And let’s talk about multifamily specifically. You got all these people that had 3 to 5 year debt that they originated back in ’21, ’22, ’23, whatever it might be. Those deals are coming to loan maturity and interest rates are double, if not more, than what they were when they originally acquired those assets. Their pro formas probably broke down. They didn’t have the rent growth they anticipated, because rent growth has been stalled, as you know, for the last couple years. It just hasn’t happened after a big run-up in ’21, ’22. So, that said, those assets — leverage cuts both ways. If it was a deal that was originated at 80% LTV, that means 20% of the equity is brought, and the deal has fallen in value by 30%, well, the equity is gone. And the lender is actually hurt as well. They have lost some of their principal balance. So these deals have to be refinanced or sold, and it’s going to be really tough to not refinance with bringing new capital in, which I think LPs that are already in the deal are going to say, “No, you already lost my money. Why would I put more in?” So these deals will probably end up going back to banks, back to lenders. We’re seeing that in our market right now. Banks are trying to figure out what they’re worth. They’re either going to sell the loans as just a transfer of the loan, maybe at a discount to the unpaid principal balance, or they’re going to transfer title and somebody else is going to come in and operate the deal. They’re going to replace the GPs. There’s going to be opportunities to get into these assets at a reduced basis that does make the deal attractive again. Everything goes in waves, right? These are cycles. So at some point, even the ugliest property on the street, there’s a number where it becomes attractive. There’s a lot of price discovery going on right now, but I think over the next couple years we’ll start to see these assets get repriced to where an investor can come in and say, “That actually looks attractive. I’m going to take a flyer on that. It’s 30% less than what somebody bought it for 4 years ago. I can make it worth more.” And if rent growth starts to take off, inflation, the tailwinds from what’s happening today — we start to get that cyclicality working in the other direction — 5 to 10 years from now, you’re going to be happy you got in. So nobody has a crystal ball. Nobody knows where things are going to be with the Fed, but these are the type of plays that make people wealthy, is when you get in at reduced asset values and ride the wave up. So.

Mindy Jensen: Everybody who is saying, “Oh, I wish I would’ve started investing in 2010.” Well, this could be your 2010, but you have to be willing to accept these bad or negative returns, or flat returns. I’m seeing, in the residential space, this is an awesome time to buy because there are people who are being forced to sell for whatever reason. I’m not writing full price offers on any properties.

Paul Shannon: Yeah, it pays to be patient with where mortgage rates are at. I see a lot of people that got really interested in vacation rentals for their own personal use, and they figured they’d have a subsidy by renting it out to others when they’re not there using it. And that hasn’t worked out at all. These luxury vacation markets, I feel like that’s a big bubble. That’s probably some forced sellers that are paying out of pocket a lot more than they thought they were to carry these second homes. There could be opportunity there. There’s a lot out there and a lot of things need to come together, but there’ll be opportunity. And I think the biggest thing an investor can do is ask themselves, “What is my risk tolerance?” Because some of the stuff we’re talking about, you have to take on risk. All investing is risky, but it varies along a spectrum. And then when you’re looking and evaluating a specific investment, you have to ask yourself, “Am I being adequately compensated for the risk that I’m taking?” So look at the 10-year Treasury today. The risk-free rate of return is about 5%. That’s pretty decent relative to short to medium-term history. If you’re only getting a 5% yield on a single-family home and you have to take out debt and handle all the headaches that come with that, is that worth it relative to the risk-free rate, the 10-year Treasury? I think it’s a healthy question to ask as you’re evaluating and comparing different assets and different investment opportunities to one another.

Mindy Jensen: Yeah, I think well-funded people who want to own more real estate than they currently do should be actively searching. My husband and I want to own a ski property either in Breckenridge or Salida. So we have searches on Breckenridge and Salida, and something interesting pops up in the search every single day. It’s not enough to drive 3 hours yet, but it soon will be.

Mindy Jensen: Back in 2008, I was searching for a Breckenridge property and one came up. It was a condo, like ski-in, ski-out, gorgeous location. First $400,000 took it, and we didn’t have $400,000 at the time. It’s now probably worth a million, a million two. It would’ve been a really great investment back then, but we didn’t have the funds. And I’m glad that it was only cash. All you could do was cash.

Paul Shannon: What’s great about that, Mindy, is that you’ve got your finger on the pulse, and you have been studying this and you know the market. So when you see a good deal next, you’re going to know it right away, right? And I think that carries over into what we’ve been talking about this whole time, is that you have to stay abreast as to what’s happening in the market, in the asset classes that you’re interested in. You have to review deal after deal after deal after deal to really get competent, to know when you have a good one. I think people get excited sometimes about whatever it might be. Let’s just say real estate investing — they hear about BiggerPockets, they go to BiggerPockets, and they’re like, “Well, let’s buy something.” And it’s like they see the first thing they see and they buy it. It’s like, well, that’s taking action. I agree. But is it the right action? Maybe not. Maybe you need to study a little bit more and get a few reps under your belt before you take that first step.

Scott Trench: I’m a fairly cautious guy, more cautious than many real estate investors, although I’ve taken action. For a while, you saw these people were not very analytical, not very strong with numbers or strategy, just building enormous amounts of wealth, buying everything willy-nilly. Now they’re having a hard time. Some of them probably bought so aggressively and with so much leverage that they’re going to really have debt problems. And others who did that did it so early and to such a degree that they’re still way richer today than they would’ve been without that approach. And sometimes I look at this one deal that I’m kind of mocking here about a little, but that deal could work out — that could produce a great return for investors — whereas a careful, good strategy deal with low fees performs poorly in here. And so how much is good analysis actually worth at the end of the day as an LP when you actually put it out there? That’s one thing I’ve kind of come to wonder: efficient market hypothesis. Are you really doing better at the end of the day than somebody who had cast their die randomly across deals over a 10, 20-year period?

Paul Shannon: I think you are. I think it’s important to know what you’re investing in and have an analytical eye on the underwriting. Even with sponsors that I’ve made money with as an LP a few times over, I still evaluate every single deal. Some people will say, “Oh, once a sponsor’s demonstrated they communicated well and they returned my capital with a return on top, I don’t really need to evaluate each individual deal. I don’t need to read the operating agreement.” I discourage that. I think it’s important to make sure that risks are continuously aligned, because people change, circumstances change, strategies change. So I think it’s critical to stay on top of that stuff. I think if you had invested back in 2015 through 2018, let’s say, in the syndication world as a limited partner, you made money no matter what you threw or who you threw the money at, right? All boats were rising in a rising tide, and cheap money, rising rents, increased interest from investors — so you had a lot more people piling in, which made the market more efficient, which increased prices and kind of made it a tighter game to play in. Everybody made money, so it didn’t matter who you invested with really, as long as you invested with somebody honest. But today it’s a different story. You have to be really on top of what your risks are, what your portfolio looks like, what void in your portfolio you’re trying to fill, and does the deal meet that objective and that return requirement? And I think that comes from studying underwriting, understanding what reality is and what it isn’t, and understanding the capabilities of the people you’re investing in — or if you’re investing in yourself, understanding what you’re capable of — having relationships with vendors, having plan A, plan B, plan C, understanding the leasing process. And today it’s a lot harder to fill units. It used to be occupancy was 95%, you just didn’t have to do much, right? Today it requires a lot more operating skills to be successful, and a lot more of a finger on the pulse of what’s happening in your market. So operators are winning today. People that just went in and thought they were going to get rich quick are losing, because they didn’t know what they were doing in the first place. So I guess, to sum it up, to answer your question, I think it’s extremely important. I think it keeps you out of trouble and has you avoid a lot more deals that you might get involved in otherwise.

Scott Trench: I think that’s right. I hope it’s right, but man, it’s—

Paul Shannon: That’s not to say that you can’t still lose money on a deal that looks great and has all the bells and whistles, right? It is still investing, and stuff does go. So that’s never going to go away, no matter what we’re investing in. There’s always a chance.

Scott Trench: Well, Paul, this has been fantastic. Can you tell us a little bit about your new book and where people can find more about you?

Paul Shannon: Yeah. First of all, I appreciate you guys having me on. It’s been a great conversation. The book’s called Both Sides of the Table. It’s available on Amazon in 3 different formats: Kindle, paperback, and hardcover. But it’s really a blueprint to investing in real estate passively and all the practices that go along with it, from diversifying to watching out for red flags to developing a strategy over the long term, to understanding debt financing and how it impacts returns and risk, to handling conversations with sponsors and what questions to ask them and how to look at private placement memorandums, and how to even use AI to help you in your journey and consolidate some of the time it requires to get to the end. My firm is called InvestWise Collective. You can check us out online, and I’m pretty active on LinkedIn too and have commentary to share when I think it’s appropriate. But LinkedIn’s getting a little bit different these days. Social media as a whole is just a different game. So less and less active there, but—

Scott Trench: Oh, I’ve been enjoying the LinkedIn posts even more lately. I feel like there’s a very robust sense of humor developing on LinkedIn that is kind of self-mocking of a lot of things and very informative. I don’t know, maybe that’s like in the last couple of months, but yes, I was not happy with it a few months ago, but I think some new rebirth has come, at least in my feed.

Paul Shannon: I got to get back to it, I guess. But yeah, it’s been great, guys. I really appreciate you having me on.

Scott Trench: Yeah, absolutely. Well, thank you so much, Paul. We’ll look forward to staying in touch and checking out the book. It was great.

Mindy Jensen: All right, Scott, that was Paul, and that was a very interesting conversation about what has worked and what kind of hasn’t worked as a real estate investor. What was your biggest takeaway?

Speaker 2: My biggest takeaway was the real estate correlation piece, right? Real estate is not highly correlated with stocks. They can both crash at the same time, they can both boom at the same time, and they can diverge, right? That’s what low correlation means here, right? It’s not saying that they will always behave separately, but this is a tough time for real estate investors, especially people in the syndication space. And I think what you heard here is the story of a prudent man who is very careful with his investment approach here and who is still having a hard time in the markets right now and bracing himself for a slog, a several years grind before the sun starts shining again and big wins come his way and he can make the next upgrades to his lifestyle. I think Paul’s among the more prudent syndicated real estate investors and passive LPs that I’ve come across. And I think that he’s still struggling here, and I think that that can happen. I don’t think the lesson is stocks versus real estate. I’m sure some people will disagree and say, well, thank God I’m in index funds, I don’t have to deal with all that headache. And there’s real truth to that, but times change, guys. Things come and go. And this position that Paul’s in would’ve been very painful from the 1997 to 2000 time period, and then very positive until 2006, 2007. So waves come and go. That’s the big takeaway that I have in this one. And this is a tough time for him in his situation, but general conservative financial management in a more general sense has enabled him to weather the storm that comes with being this highly correlated to one type of asset.

Mindy Jensen: Yeah. If you were thinking about investing in real estate and this episode has you saying, “ooh, nevermind,” great. Then this episode has done its job. I don’t want anybody investing in real estate who doesn’t want to invest in real estate and doesn’t understand the risks that are involved in real estate. But if you listen to this episode and you’re like, “okay, I can learn something from this, it hasn’t deterred me yet,” great. Continue on, continue learning, continue looking for your next deal. I think that it is an excellent time to buy real estate right now for the well-funded, well-educated, very knowledgeable person who wants to invest in real estate. But it is absolutely a buyer’s market. I’m seeing this myself. If anybody wants to live in Longmont, my personal house is for sale and nobody wants to buy it. It’s awesome. So I am just sitting on it right now, but it will eventually sell. I just have a really bad time putting it on the market.

Speaker 2: When did you put it on the market?

Mindy Jensen: I put it on the market two days after the Fed raised rates last.

Speaker 2: What date? What was it? What month?

Mindy Jensen: September, either 18th or 19th.

Speaker 2: Mindy, you know, you got to list that thing in May.

Mindy Jensen: My other house wasn’t ready to list in May.

Speaker 2: Fair enough. Fair enough.

Mindy Jensen: A lot of bad circumstances all coming together. And like, really, Scott, I’m gonna make $300,000 on that property. So it’s fine. And I’m well funded, so I can ride it out. It’s just, it’s a great time to be a buyer. I have buyer clients right now, and we’re not making full price offers on any properties that we’re seeing. It’s not even close.

Speaker 2: One more note on Paul’s approach here. Very rarely do you meet this person in the wild, and Paul is no exception. He’s not one of these people, but the syndicated real estate asset class, in my opinion, is an absolutely terrible thing to put most or all of your investment wealth in, right? And the reason for it is the fees. So the pendulum swings in all these deals. You may get some really nice returns for a period of time, and you might get crushed every once in a while in this asset class generally and in any specific deal. But across a large sampling, this is going to underperform the stock market over a long period of time. It just will, because the fees are much more expensive than low-fee passively managed index funds. And even because of the scale, the fees that are paid to executive management at corporations, you will underperform over a long period of time. The purpose, I believe, of these syndicated real estate investments is to express specific theses that can potentially outperform, or to get some kind of diversification and low correlation with the other holdings in your portfolio. And so even Paul, you can see, has 20% of his wealth in these deals, not 50%. The reason he approaches that number is because that is his business. He is literally an active capital raiser in some capacity, and it’s like having a small business in this area. So there’s a reason for that. This is one of the more exposed people to the space. But even among his truly passive wealth, this is a minority of his holdings. He’s got stocks and the other 15% in a smattering of holdings there. So just want to call that out from an approach here. I love talking about this space. I’m personally invested in it. This is not a place to go huge in, in my opinion, because of the statistical disadvantage you have over a long period of time relative to something like a passively managed index fund.

Mindy Jensen: Yep. Absolutely agree. All right, Scott, should we get out of here?

Speaker 2: Let’s do it.

Mindy Jensen: Okay. Our dear listeners, we know that you have a lot of trouble finding fee-only or advice-only, not AUM, advisors who also understand financial independence. Scott and I are building out a network of these professionals and more over at biggerpocketsmoney.com/fipro. That’s biggerpocketsmoney.com/fipro. All right, that wraps up this episode of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast. He is Scott Trench, I am Mindy Jensen, saying later, tater.

Brand New! (June 2026) BiggerPockets Money App

Close Welcome Bar